Why Default Nudge Works

How to cite

Watanabe, Yasutora; Kawaguchi, Kohei; Uetake, Kosuke; Yamada, Katsunori; Suzuki, Kanji; Chikazoe, Junichi. 2024. "Why Default Nudge Works." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012458. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12458-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yasutora Watanabe* , Kohei Kawaguchi , Kosuke Uetake , Katsunori Yamada , Kanji Suzuki , Junichi Chikazoe

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012458
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12458-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-02-05 – 2024-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D91, C91, D01
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12458

Abstract

We study the mechanism of why default nudge works. To investigate this question, we consider three factors suggested in the literature; ease, endowment, and endorsement. To consider how these factors affect default nudge, we conduct an online experiment and a fMRI experiment. In these experiments, we ask series of binary choice questions to the subjects in which subject faces the five treatments: i) no default nudge, ii) simple default nudge where one alternative is selected as default, iii) default nudge with ease where the questions are asked with many words so that the subject will find it easy to choose the default choice, iv) default nudge with endowment where the default choice is associated with endowment effect, and v) default nudge with endorsement where the default choice is associated with endorsement in the question. After understanding how these factors affect the default nudge, we employ an fMRI experiment to explore the neural basis of the emotional aspect of the mechanism of how these factors influence the effectiveness of the default nudge.

Intervention

We ask our respondents about repeated binary choice questions. Our interventions are about "default" options for binary choice questions.

Specifically, we have one control condition in which subjects make binary choice without default nudge, and the following four treatment conditions in which the subjects make binary decisions with the following default nudge:
i) simple default nudge where one alternative is selected as default,
ii) default nudge with ease where the questions are asked with many words so that the subject will find it easy to choose the default choice,
iii) default nudge with endowment where the default choice is associated with endowment effect, and
iv) default nudge with endorsement where the default choice is associated with endorsement in the question.

With the design, we investigate how much the default nudges increase the propensity to select "favorable" options and what would be the mechanism when default nudge works.

Experimental design

Subjects in our online survey experiment (main study) respond to 10 binary choice questions. The contexts of binary choice questions are the ones used in extant default nudge studies, such as whether to participate in activities related to environmental conservation, join a pension plan, or donate to charitable causes. There are five types of question modalities, and our respondents answer two for each modality, resulting in 10 total questions.

For each of the five modalities, the subjects are randomly assigned to one of the following:
1) Control where there is no default nudge,
2) simple default nudge in which one alternative is selected as default,
3) default nudge with ease where the questions are asked with many words so that the subject will find it easy to choose the default choice,
4) default nudge with endowment where the default choice is associated with endowment effect, and
5) default nudge with endorsement where the default choice is associated with endorsement in the question.

Patterns (3) - (5) are prepared to investigate potential mechanism why default nudge may work, that is the effect of ease, that of persuasion, and that of endowment, respectively.

In our analysis, after summarizing the descriptive statistics of the experiment, we regress the choices in each question onto the dummy variables for treatments (2) to (5) with and without different types of controls.

For fMRI experiment, each subject answers 50 questions, that is treatments (1) to (5) for two questions for each 5 modalities. For fMRI experiment, analysis using fMRI images will be conducted.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done in an office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is at the individual level.
Clusters
1500 individuals for online experiment and 35 individuals for fMRI experiment
Observations
1500 individuals for online experiment and 50 for fMRI experiment
Arms
For the online survey experiment, we have five different modality of questions, which we regard to be different experiments. As each subject answer 10 total questions, each subject answers two questions for each modality. We manipulate them with how defaults are set for these binary questions. Since there are five different treatment conditions (including a control condition), each treatment arm for the online survey has (1500x10)/(5x5) = 120.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variable for the survey experiment is the choices for the binary choice questions.
Sponsors
Name: Japan Society for Promotion of Science Location: Tokyo Japan Url: https://www.jsps.go.jp/english/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords