Gender differences in willingness to lead, the role of confidence

How to cite

Rapoport, Nina; Bouleau, Clémentine; Gangadharan, Lata. 2023. "Gender differences in willingness to lead, the role of confidence." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012440. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12440-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nina Rapoport* , Clémentine Bouleau , Lata Gangadharan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012440
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12440-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-07 – 2023-12-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J24, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12440

Abstract

This project explores gender differences in willingness to lead (WTL) in a controlled laboratory environment, and seeks to identify underlying mechanisms. The primary goal of the study is to explore the effect of confidence on willingness to lead. In particular, we ask whether women are more hesitant to become leaders because they are less confident in their ability, and in which leadership setting confidence is more likely to drive the decision to become leader. To isolate the effect of confidence on WTL, factors such as performance, risk aversion, and gender stereotypes are measured, and backlash against female leaders is ruled out as total anonymity is maintained. The study examines two different contexts of leadership. In the first context, which we call ‘responsibility’, leaders are responsible for making decisions on behalf of the group following input from group members. In the second, which we call ‘influence’, followers make their own decisions, but leaders have the opportunity to persuade the group to adopt their viewpoint. These settings are designed such that the effort required from leaders (writing a message to explain their rationale) is identical between the two, and the difference lies in how the leader’s input determines payoffs. Participants are randomly assigned to one of these two settings and perform the same task twice, once individually and once as part of a group. The task is identical in both settings and consists in ranking objects according to their importance for survival in different scenarios. In line with previous research, we expect to find that women are reluctant to volunteer for leadership roles. We hypothesize that gender differences in confidence explain a significant part of the gender gap in WTL.

Experimental design

Part I
a. Individual work - participants work individually on a task outlining a survival situation. They answer a series of question consisting in selecting which items they find most important for survival. We use an expert solution to evaluate these answers and determine payoffs in the different parts of the experiment.
b. Confidence elicitation - we measure participants' confidence in their answers on several confidence dimensions (precision, estimation, placement).

Part 2
a. Appointment of a group leader - participants are informed that they will perform a similar task involving a different survival situation. They are also told that they are grouped with 3 other participants in the session, with whom they will work for this task. Before starting Part 2.b, a group leader will be appointed, whose role depends on the leadership setting participants have been randomly attributed to. They are only informed about their specific leadership setting: In the first setting, leaders are responsible for making decisions on behalf of the group following input from group members. In the second, followers make their own decisions, but leaders have the opportunity to persuade the group to adopt their viewpoint. Once participants are informed of these procedures, they indicate how much they want to become the leader, on a scale between 1 and 10 (“Willingness to Lead”). The group members who indicate the highest motivation are selected to become group leaders.
b. Group work - following the procedures described above, participants complete the second task.
c. Confidence elicitation: - We elicit beliefs about (individual) performance in the second part, and, depending on treatment and role, a belief on group dynamics
d. Evaluation of Leader - group members are asked to evaluate the leader's performance on a scale from 1 to 10, and leaders are asked to evaluate their own performance as a leader on the same scale. Non-leaders also rate their satisfaction with the leader's integration of the group's input (setting 1) or the extent to which they found the leader's justification message (setting 2).

Part 3 - IAT Test, Questionnaire, and Payment
a. IAT - participants take an implicit association test (IAT), eliciting the strength of their implicit associations between leadership and being male.
b. Questionnaire - participants answer questions about their gender identity, willingness to take risks, beliefs about gender differences in task performance, attitudes on gender and leadership, previous leadership experience and motivation for their answer to the WTL question. We collect demographic information on age, gender and occupation/field of study.
c. Feedback and Payment - participants receive feedback on their performance in Part 1 and 2. They also have the opportunity to view the experts' solutions to better understand their scores. One the two parts of the experiment is randomly selected to determine payment.

Design details

Randomization method
Experimenters determine treatment assignment for each session. Participants are assigned to treatments based on the session they sign up for.
Randomization unit
Treatments are assigned at the session level. Participants are assigned to treatments based on the session they sign up for. Within a given session, participants (~20 per session) are randomly assigned to groups of four by the experimental program (OTree). They do not get any information about group members for the whole duration of the experiment, and the limited feedback they receive about the behavior of group members is presented after we gather the main outcomes of performance, WTL and beliefs on own performance. We thus consider randomization to be at the individual level for our main analyses, and refer to this unit for the fields below.
Clusters
280 participants
Observations
280 participants
Arms
140 participants per treatment
Primary outcomes
Willingness to lead Individual performance Confidence in performance (overestimation, overplacement, overprecision)
Secondary outcomes
Explicit and implicit gender attitudes Risk attitudes Leaders’ evaluation Text of leader's messages Gender identity questions Demographic information - age, gender, occupation, field of study for students

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords