The Impacts of Female Education: Evidence from Malawian Secondary Schools

How to cite

Kim, Hyuncheol; Choi, Syngjoo; Pop-Eleches, Cristian; Kim, Booyuel. 2016. "The Impacts of Female Education: Evidence from Malawian Secondary Schools." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001243. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1243-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hyuncheol Kim* , Syngjoo Choi , Cristian Pop-Eleches , Booyuel Kim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001243
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1243-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2011-10-03 – 2016-08-31
Countries
Malawi (Rural Lilongwe)
JEL codes
I25, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1243

Abstract

This project evaluates a randomized controlled trial of an education support program for girls on rationality and preferences. Between October of 2011 and May of 2012 a baseline survey of 7,971 secondary students in school cohorts 9-11 was implemented across 124 classrooms in 33 public secondary schools in Malawi. One intervention arm of the study was targeted towards the 3,997 female students in the sample and randomly provided to a subgroup one-year tuition support and monthly cash stipends. For this study we have selected the 2811 students who were in grade 9 and 10 in 2012 (since those in grade 11 have graduated and are harder to track). This study aims to understand the impact of this education intervention on rationality and preferences in decision making under risk and over time. These outcomes will be measured using experimental methods based on previous work by one of the authors of the study (Choi, Fisman, Gale, and Kariv, AER, 2007; Choi, Kariv, Müller, and Silverman, AER, 2014).

[Added in 2019 Dec] Further, we implemented phone surveys in 2017 (3rd follow-up) and 2019 (4th follow-up). In these surveys, we measure labor market outcomes and post-schooling training, marital status and partner information, sexual relationships, and attitudes toward male circumcision, pregnancy and contraceptive usage (females only). In the 2019 survey, we additionally introduced two types of outcome variables to understand the impacts of secondary school education on 1) political preference and participation, and 2) health knowledge and health investment behaviors.

The first set of outcome variables capture political preferences and participation. We measured preferences at the second follow-up survey including 1) interest in politics, 2) views on various political issues, and 3) views on political systems, democracy, and elections. We also ask questions on participation in politics in the fourth follow-up survey, which was implemented right after the nation-wide protest related to election fraud in mid 2019.

The second set of outcome variables are health knowledge and investment behaviors. We introduce a simple test to measure level of knowledge about malaria. We also provide an opportunity for study participants to pick up a free multi vitamin (which is worth about $10) in designated shops in the city center to measure health investment behavior.

Intervention

For the school year 2012-2013, all girl students in the treatment classrooms received one-year school tuition (three semesters) and monthly cash stipends (three times per semester). School tuition and fees per semester on average was 3,500 Malawi kwacha and were directly deposited to each school's account and monthly cash stipends of 300 Malawi kwacha were distributed to treated students, which is equivalent to in total around US$ 70 per year.

Experimental design

Treatment: 62 classrooms across 9th ~ 11th grade were randomly selected in 2012 to receive school tuition and monthly cash stipends over one year (three semesters).
Control: 62 classrooms across 9th ~ 11th grade were randomly selected as control group and no school tuition and cash stipends were provided

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization of classrooms in office by computer random number generator
Randomization unit
Classroom
Clusters
2,811 completed baseline surveys for women (baseline 9th and 10th grade) who will be targeted in this 3-year follow-up study coming from 33schools and 83 classes
Observations
We expect to successfully interview about 91% (Effective Survey Rate) of women from the initial baseline for a total of 2,811 women (excluding baseline 11th grade students).
Arms
treatment: 39 classrooms (1,459 women) control: 44 classrooms (1,352 women)
Primary outcomes
Main outcome variables include 1) measures of rationality and preferences, and 2) HIV and HSV2 infection. 1. Rationality: We use revealed preferences analysis to check whether subjects’ behavior comply with utility maximization hypothesis. It will be done by checking whether individual behavior is consistent with Generalized Axiom of Revealed Preferences (GARP) and measuring the extent to which it violates GARP. We use various indices of measuring GARP violations, including Afriat’s Critical Cost Efficiency Index (CCEI). This will be separately done in domains of decision making under risk as well as of intertemporal choices. 2. Risk preferences: Experimental data of choices under risk will allow us to measure two distinct parameters of risk attitudes-utility curvature and probability weighting. This will be based on parametric estimation of rank-dependent utility model (Quiggin, 1981; Schmeidler, 1989). We will also use a single, nonparametric measure of risk attitudes. 3. Time preferences: Using experimental data of intertemporal choices, we will measure two parameters of time impatience-present bias and standard discount rate. This will be based on parametric estimation of quasi-hyperbolic discounting utility model (Laibson, 1997). Also, a single, nonparametric measure of time impatience will be used. 4. HIV and HSV2 infection: We will measure infection of HIV and HSV2 by the rapid test kits. 5. Political preference and participation: We measure 1) interest and participation in politics, 2) views on various political issues, and 3) views on political systems, democracy, and elections in the second follow-up survey. In the fourth follow-up survey, we additionally measure participation in recent nation-wide protests related to election fraud. 6. Health knowledge and investment behavior: We measure respondents’ level of knowledge about malaria. We also provide an opportunity for study participants to pick up a free multi vitamin (which value is about $10) in a designated shop to measure health investment behavior.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords