Revitalizing Traditional Water Tanks for Climate Adaptation in India
How to cite
Bhogale, Shweta; Bagga, Aanchal; Emerick, Kyle. 2024. "Revitalizing Traditional Water Tanks for Climate Adaptation in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012398. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12398-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Irrigation allows farmers to adapt to heat stress or droughts. However, the threat of groundwater depletion and uneven access to irrigation make it an incomplete adaptation response. This project assesses how public goods, like water reservoirs that enhance widespread irrigation access through collecting and storing rainwater, can facilitate climate adaptation. We test the effectiveness of such tanks by studying the constraints they face from farmers' irrigation responses and other input markets like water and labor.
In the Bundelkhand region of central India, traditional tanks were constructed centuries ago to store rainwater for irrigation during the next dry season. The tanks have accumulated silt over time reducing their capacity and ability to source water in the dry season. Our intervention will deepen these tanks to improve their volume and facilitate underground drainage of harvested water. Farmers can access this water directly from the tank through pumps or increased water levels in their wells. This intervention could either equip farmers with the necessary irrigation to improve their productivity and mitigate the negative effects of climate shocks, or, it could lead farmers to undo the positive effects of the tank by disproportionately increasing water extraction as a response to the increased water supply. The effects of the tank may also be susceptible to "elite capture" through large farmers using costly equipment to monopolize the resource in the local water market. Therefore, we also evaluate how an individually targeted intervention like training on conservative and climate-robust agriculture affects the resilience, productivity, and efficiency of groundwater use. Our design tests the extent to which the training can substitute or complement the tank renovation intervention. Last, we will measure how the tank affects labor supply and demand on the farms and whether this is likely to moderate the effects of the intervention on climate adaptation.
Intervention
There are two kinds of interventions involved:
1) Tank renovation: villages could have two kinds of structures - tanks, which are like man-made lakes/reservoirs, and ‘dohas’, which are saucer-shaped structures dug in the stream bed along its length separated into multiple, smaller water ponds by mud dams to prevent overflow. The water tanks/dohas were originally built at the foot of a hill or a natural slope to capture rainwater during the monsoon (June-September) and they formed the main source of stored water in these villages. Currently, after accumulating silt over 1000 years, the tanks/dohas have reduced volumes of water and tend to run completely dry by February/March, restricting farmers’ ability to crop and irrigate all of their cultivable lands in the dry season, and limiting the water available for domestic activities and livestock rearing. SRIJAN is engaged in renovating these tanks by digging out 8-10 ft of the silt across the whole structure which will increase its carrying capacity such that the water could last longer, ideally until the next monsoon hits.
2) Training: The training intervention involves repeated sessions with the NGO’s experts before and during the dry season (November to May) that cover different aspects of agricultural practices that can improve yields, make the crop robust to shocks, and enhance water efficiency on the farm.
Experimental design
This project evaluates the individual and complementary effects of public and private climate adaptation tools for farmers in the context of publicly managed water reservoirs and training targeted to farmer’s individual investments. These villages could have two kinds of structures - tanks, which are like man-made lakes/reservoirs, and ‘dohas’, which are saucer-shaped structures dug in the stream bed along its length separated into multiple, smaller water ponds by mud dams to prevent overflow. The water tanks/dohas were originally built at the foot of a hill or a natural slope to capture rainwater during the monsoon (June-September) and they formed the main source of stored water in these villages. Currently, after accumulating silt over 1000 years, the tanks/dohas have reduced volumes of water and tend to run completely dry by February/March, restricting farmers’ ability to crop and irrigate all of their cultivable lands in the dry season, and limiting the water available for domestic activities and livestock rearing.
Villages were randomized into treatment groups by stratifying on state and whether they have a tank or a doha, since the effects of a doha may be more locally concentrated relative to a tank. Our design is a 2X2 RCT with the following treatment groups:
Treatment 1: 39 villages. Tanks/Dohas renovation only.
Treatment 2: 39 villages. Training only.
Treatment 3: 38 villages. Tank/Doha Renovation + Training.
Control group: 38 villages. Neither.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.