What Attracts and Deters Women from Economics?

How to cite

Cranney, Katelyn; Gee, Laura; Stoddard, Olga; Buzard, Kristy. 2023. "What Attracts and Deters Women from Economics?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012381. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12381-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Katelyn Cranney* , Laura Gee , Olga Stoddard , Kristy Buzard

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012381
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12381-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-10-27 – 2025-10-27
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D01, M50
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12381

Abstract

Economics and other STEM fields like Mathematics are dominated by men, but research finds that simple low cost informational interventions can impact interest in economics, and that higher-cost mentoring interventions–especially from women–have the potential to attract more women to these fields. By administering information and providing mentor opportunities to women at the early stages of their education, we can increase the number of women in these fields and lessen the gender gap. We propose a multi-step, multi-site, theory informed randomized controlled trial (RCT) designed to increase the presence and success of women throughout the economics discipline while also measuring interest in Mathematics. First, we will administer an incentive-compatible pre-survey to high school and college students investigating what attributes attract women to Economics. This will inform the design of our RCT. Second, we will run a theoretically-informed RCT on college and high school students which randomizes informational interventions that highlight one of the pre-survey informed attributes that attract women to economics (e.g. mentoring). Our theoretical model predicts that by sending both high and low signals about a specific attribute, we can disentangle the effect of beliefs about this attribute versus other deterrents in pushing women away from Economics and Mathematics. Through our collaboration with the respective partners, we will measure self-reported interest in Economics and Mathematics for all of our sample, subsequent course enrollments/grades for those in our college sample as well as interest/completion of a college peer mentoring program. We will concentrate our analysis on measuring interest in courses, majors and minors in both Economics and Mathematics. Third, for those in our college sample who are interested in peer-mentoring, we randomize whether they receive mentoring from a male or female mentor in an important extension of Canaan and Mouganie (2021).

Intervention

We will collect data from high school, college, and general population surveys about what attributes attract and deters students from studying Economics which we expect also deter them from other STEM fields like Mathematics. We will use the results of this survey to design an information intervention. We will test whether this information intervention increases likelihoods that students are interested in economics and mathematics.

Experimental design

First, we will administer a pre-survey to high school and college students investigating what attributes attract women to Economics. This will inform the design of our RCT.

Second, we will run a theoretically-informed RCT on college and high school students which randomizes informational interventions that highlight one of the pre-survey informed attributes that attract women to economics. We will measure self-reported interest in Economics and Mathematics for all of our sample, subsequent course enrollments/grades for those in our college sample as well as interest/completion of a peer mentoring program.

Finally, for those in our college sample who are interested in peer-mentoring, we randomize whether they receive mentoring from a male or female mentor. Again, we will observe self-reported interest in Economics/Mathematics and subsequent course enrollment/grades.

Design details

Randomization method
We will randomize using an online statistical software tool.
Randomization unit
We will randomize at the student level, possibly group level.
Clusters
We plan to cluster at the subject level, and we hope to have approximately 10,000 subjects in our study.
Observations
In total, we plan to have approximately 10,000 subjects in our study, with the majority of those being first year students at Tufts, Syracuse, and Brigham Young University
Arms
For the informational treatment, we will randomize one-third of the sample at each site to each message (baseline, economics low signal, economics high signal). For those who express interest in a peer-mentoring program, we plan to randomize whether they are paired with a female or a male senior peer mentor. We will stagger the timing of mentoring so that we can measure the effects of both any mentoring and female mentoring. Here we will likely have fewer female mentors than male mentors available so the treatments may not be balanced, but we hope to randomize half of our sample to a male mentor and half of our sample to a female mentor.
Primary outcomes
We also plan to elicit within the same survey respondents’ interest in Economics, their beliefs about the attributes we identified in our pre-survey, and whether they would be interested in enrolling in an Economics mentoring program. These are our short-term primary outcomes.
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary long-term outcomes are whether students enroll in an Economics/Mathematics course and whether they express interest in an Economics mentoring program. We will administer periodic surveys to our high school and college sample to measure self-reported interest in Economics/Mathematics and beliefs about the attributes identified in the pre-survey. For our college sample we will also measure course enrollments, grades, major and minor selection over the subsequent years after our informational intervention and mentoring intervention with a particular interest in identifying interest in Economics and Mathematics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords