The role of a motivational account and of specificity of belief measures in overconfidence about personal saving behavior

How to cite

Prins, Carlijn; Rosenkranz, Stephanie; Dijk, Wilco van. 2023. "The role of a motivational account and of specificity of belief measures in overconfidence about personal saving behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012378. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12378-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Carlijn Prins* , Stephanie Rosenkranz , Wilco van Dijk

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012378
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12378-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-27 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12378

Abstract

The goal of this research is to investigate biased beliefs about personal saving behavior. Biased beliefs in this study are operationalized as overconfidence, comparing an individual’s beliefs about personal saving behavior to an individual’s beliefs about saving behavior of others. This form of overconfidence is also known as the better-than-average effect. Furthermore, by experimentally varying the importance to save, we will be able to test whether overconfidence about personal saving behavior has a motivational account. Also, we will investigate whether specificity of the beliefs measures affects the level of overconfidence. And we will look into the interaction between importance to save and specificity of the beliefs measures. We designed a 2 by 2 online experiment, where both the importance of saving and the specificity of the belief measures are varied. The results of the experiment will have relevance for understanding personal saving behavior and for the development of interventions to help people improve their saving behavior.

Intervention

We will conduct a 2 (motivation: importance-salient / importance-not-salient) by 2 (specificity of beliefs measure: vague / specific) between subjects online experiment. Respondents will be randomly assigned to one of the four conditions. We will vary motivation by presenting respondents one of two short texts. Respondents in the importance-salient condition will read the following text about the importance of saving:

Saving money contributes to a happy life and is therefore important and desirable to do. You can use savings to pay for major expenses in the future or to do fun things. Savings also provide you a buffer for unexpected expenses and financial setbacks. Saving makes your life better, gives you more security and peace of mind and fewer financial worries.

Respondents in the importance-not-salient condition will read the following neutral text about money:

Money can take different forms. There is cash, but money can also be in your checking or savings account. Money has three different functions, regardless of its form. It is a store of value. Money is also a medium of exchange, which means a means of payment in which everyone has confidence. In addition, money is also a unit of account in which you can express the price of goods and services.

After being presented with one of the texts, respondents will read a short explanation about the definition of savings. After that, respondents will answer questions to measure beliefs about their own saving behavior and about saving behavior of peers in the same living situation. The order of self/other beliefs will be counterbalanced. Furthermore, the specificity of the beliefs measures will be varied. Respondents in the vague condition will answer more vague beliefs measures about saving behavior, while those in the specific condition will answer more specific measures (see the details in the description of the primary outcomes). In both the vague and specific condition, there will be three belief items about own behavior and three about others’ behavior. In the vague condition all three items will be counterbalanced, in the specific condition two of the three will be counterbalanced (see the details in the description of the primary outcomes). Next, the texts to vary motivation are presented again so that afterwards the effect of the motivation manipulation can be measured by asking respondents how important they think saving is.

All materials used in this study are designed and distributed in Dutch. The Dutch materials are definitive and are added as Appendix 1 in the PDF ‘Pre-registration of research design and analysis plan’. Due to translation choices, the English versions of the texts and questions used in this study might change in the final paper.

Experimental design

Our experiment will be part of an online survey held amongst Dutch young adults. The survey is about saving behavior, living situation, financial situation and financial decisions. Our experiment will be the first part of the survey. Respondents will be recruited via consumer panel Dynata and respondents will receive a small financial compensation for their participation, which is being paid by Dynata. The experiment will be conducted once.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomize at the individual level (respondent) applying a non-stratified randomization design using least fill method for all four conditions. Randomization is done by a computer.
Randomization unit
We randomize at the individual level (respondent)
Clusters
No clusters.
Observations
We aim to recruit around 1600 Dutch adults aged of 18 up to and including 30 years.
Arms
We aim to recruit around 1600 Dutch adults aged of 18 up to and including 30 years. Our aim is that respondents are evenly distributed among the four experimental conditions. That would mean 400 respondents in importance-salient-vague condition, 400 respondents in importance-salient-specific condition, 400 respondents in importance-not-salient-vague condition and 400 respondents in importance-not-salient-specific condition.
Primary outcomes
Overconfidence about personal saving behavior, beliefs about personal saving behavior, beliefs about saving behavior of peers in the same life sitation.
Secondary outcomes
The importance of saving

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords