Closing the Gap: The Effects of Multifaceted School Intervention on Left-behind Children

How to cite

wu, jia; Wang, Chunchao. 2023. "Closing the Gap: The Effects of Multifaceted School Intervention on Left-behind Children." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012375. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12375-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

jia wu* , Chunchao Wang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012375
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12375-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-01-01 – 2021-07-30
Countries
China (Hunan)
JEL codes
J13, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12375

Abstract

The experiment was implemented in 23 elementary schools in Yunmeng County in Hubei province of China. At the beginning of the spring semester in 2017–2018 school year, students from 3rd to 5th grades in the 23 schools participated in a baseline survey. Based on the information collected in the baseline survey, we can identify the left-behind children. We randomly selected 23 primary schools (145 classes) from 46 public primary schools to participate our experiment in the second semester in 2017-2018 school year. We design two treatment arms. First, video calling intervention. The video calling was directed by class head teachers, who participated in a training meeting to learn how to implement the video calling intervention. Each week, teachers spend two 10-minute sessions using their cell phones to give a video phone call to parents of left-behind children. The teacher schedules a time at the parents’ convenience, usually at lunchtime. After the time is agreed upon by the parents, the teacher takes the child to his/her office (or a spare room if there are people around) and provides their cell phone to let the child talk to their migrant parents by video call. Second, after-school tutoring intervention. After the last class in the afternoon, treated left-behind children took a 40-minute tutoring class, instructed by teachers. Each week, students have two lessons, one for Chinese and the other for mathematics. The content of class is to review the knowledge in the past days in the week. The treated children in the same grade and school were located in a spare classroom and instructed by a recruited teacher.

Intervention

We conducted our program in a nearby county of Yunmeng in a pilot study in 2017. The pilot experiment includes 6 schools. The treatment effects of video-calling and after-school tutoring interventions on mathematic scores, neuroticism, and extraversion are approximately 0.2 standard deviations/points.

The approach of selecting treated and control group relies on a class randomization scheme at the school-by-grade level. If there are 3 or more classes in a grade of a school, we divided the number of the classes by 3 and round the number down to the nearest integer. Then, VC, AT, and (between-class) control classes were assigned with the same number of classes according to that integer. The remaining classes (i.e., the number of classes left after the division) were randomly assigned as VC and AT classes. If there are fewer than 3 classes in a grade of a school, these classes are randomly assigned to VC, AT, and control. Following this rule, we have 55 VC treatment classes (498 left-behind children), 56 AT treated classes (466 left-behind students), and 34 control classes (283 left-behind students). For each of the 111 treatment classes, we randomly selected two-thirds of left-behind children to receive the treatment. The remaining one-third in the same classes were assigned as within-class controls. Finally, 348 left-behind children are receiving VC intervention in 55 VC treatment classes, among which 150 students are within-class controls. 326 left-behind children receiving AT intervention in 56 classes, among which 140 students are within-class controls.

A follow-up survey tracked 951 left-behind children (76%) of the original sample three years later (July 2021). The sample includes 268 and 249 students who previously received VC and AT interventions and 220 students who were previously in the control group.

Experimental design

The experiment was implemented in 23 elementary schools in Yunmeng County in Hubei province of China. At the beginning of the spring semester in 2017–2018 school year, students from 3rd to 5th grades in the 23 schools participated in a baseline survey. Based on the information collected in the baseline survey, we can identify the left-behind children. We randomly selected 23 primary schools (145 classes) from 46 public primary schools to participate our experiment in the second semester in 2017-2018 school year. We design two treatment arms, namely, video-calling internvetion and after-school tutoring intervention.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Class and individual.
Clusters
145 classes
Observations
1247 left-behind children in 145 classes of 23 primary schools
Arms
55 video-calling classes, 56 after-schooling tutoring classes, and 34 control classes.
Primary outcomes
After-school tutoring intervention leads to an increase in mathematics scores for left-behind children. Video-calling intervention significantly improves children’s neuroticism, extraversion, and conscientiousness. The positive effects of video calling persist for nearly three years after the intervention.
Sponsors
Name: National Natural Science Foundation of China Location: China Url: https://www.nsfc.gov.cn/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords