Preferences for Network Partners

How to cite

Rincke, Johannes; Nagler, Markus; Högn, Celina. 2023. "Preferences for Network Partners." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012348. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12348-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Johannes Rincke* , Markus Nagler , Celina Högn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012348
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12348-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-10-24 – 2025-07-31
Countries
Germany ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12348

Abstract

We run a stated choice experiment to estimate preferences for network members among university freshmen. In the experiment, newly enrolled students at a large German university state for a number of ficticious profiles of fellow students whether or not they consider subjects with the respective profiles as potential network partners. Using this data, we plan to estimate to what extent homophily shapes network preferences.

Intervention

We run a stated-choice experiment among newly enrolled undergraduate students at a large public University in Germany. Participants state, for a series of ficticious profiles of fellow students, whether or not they consider subjects with respective profiles as potential network partners. Profiles are described by characteristics (study field, gender, mother tongue other than German, main study motive, A-level GPA) and personality traits (conscientiousness, altruism, competitiveness, self-efficacy). In all dimensions, attributes are randomly drawn.

Experimental design

We run a stated-choice online experiment among newly enrolled undergraduate students at a large public University in Germany. Participants state, for a series of ficticious profiles of fellow students, whether or not they consider subjects with respective profiles as potential network partners. Profiles are described by characteristics (study field, gender, mother tongue other than German, main study motive, A-level GPA) and personality traits (conscientiousness, altruism, competitiveness, self-efficacy). In all dimensions, attributes are randomly drawn. 'Mother tongue other than German' is either empty or takes values 'Spanish', 'Turkish', or 'Arabian'. The dimensions A-level GPA and all traits take values 'above average=yes' or 'above average=no'. Participants state, for each profile separately, whether or not they consider a given profile as representing a potential network partner. The stated choices are incentivized: Subjects are informed that after the survey, they will be invited to an online networking event where they will be matched with fellow students in accordance with the (mutually stated) preferences over network partners. Subjects who truthfully state their preferences thus increase their chances to meet fellow students with preferred charcteristics. To test to what extent stated preferences reflect preferences over mating partners rather than network partners, three out of the nine profiles rated in total do not contain information on gender. Using only the subset of profiles without gender information, we will test to what extent preferences obtained from the set of complete profiles are robust to not revealing gender (and thus closing down the mating channel). Our main interest is understanding to what extent network preferences are shaped by homophily. Specifically, we plan to run estimations where the dependent variable will be an indicator for whether or not subjects consider a given profile as representing a potential network partner. The regressors will be differences between the subjects own characteristics and traits and those of the respective profile. Standard errors will be clustered at the level of the subject (participant).

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer, implemented in an online environment programmed by the researchers
Randomization unit
randomization is done at the level of the individual profile (ficticious potential network partner)
Clusters
We plan to invite 3577 newly enrolled undergraduate students and expect a participation rate of about 50 percent.
Observations
We plan to invite 3577 newly enrolled undergraduate students and expect a participation rate of about 50 percent. Each subject will rate 9 profiles. The number of observations will thus be 3577 x (partcipation rate) x 9.
Arms
Profiles randomly vary in all dimension. Thus, there are no 'treatment arms' as in a classical RCT.
Primary outcomes
Indicator for whether or not subjects consider a given profile as representing a potential network partner
Secondary outcomes
We will run robustness checks using an indicator defining a profile as 'accepted as network partner' if the response is 'yes' or 'maybe'.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords