Behind the GATE Experiment: Evidence on Effects of and Rationales for Subsidized Entrepreneurship Training

How to cite

Karlan, Dean; Zinman, Jonathan; Fairlie, Robert W.. 2016. "Behind the GATE Experiment: Evidence on Effects of and Rationales for Subsidized Entrepreneurship Training." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001234. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1234-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Dean Karlan* , Jonathan Zinman , Robert W. Fairlie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001234
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1234-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2003-09-01 – 2008-09-30
Countries
United States of America (North America)
JEL codes
I26, J24, J68, L25, L26, M13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1234

Abstract

Theories of market failures and targeting motivate the promotion of entrepreneurship training programs and generate testable predictions regarding heterogeneous treatment effects from such programs. Using a large randomized evaluation in the United States, we find no strong or lasting effects on those most likely to face credit or human capital constraints, or labor market discrimination. We do find a short-run effect on business ownership for those unemployed at baseline, but this dissipates at longer horizons. Treatment effects on the full sample are also short-term and limited in scope: we do not find effects on business sales, earnings, or employees.

Intervention

Growing America through Entrepreneurship (Project GATE) was an evaluation designed and implemented by the U.S. Department of Labor and U.S. Small Business Association. The GATE experiment is the largest-ever randomized evaluation of entrepreneurship training and assistance, involving more than four thousand participants. Using Project GATE, we tested whether self-employment training effectively reduces difficulties that individuals face in identifying and securing employment by providing them with skills to start or expand small businesses. GATE was administered between September 2003 and July 2005 in seven cities of varying sizes. Fourteen different organizations provided the GATE training, including Small Business Association-funded and non-profit community-based organizations, all of which had been in operation prior to the experiment.

More than four thousand individuals applied for a limited number of slots for free entrepreneurship training services. Applicants were informed “GATE does not have space for everyone” and that a “lottery or random drawing will decide whether you will be able to enter the program.” Applicants assigned to receive the program were then offered an array of best-practice training services, beginning with a one-on-one assessment meeting to determine an individual’s specific training needs. Subjects assigned to the comparison group were not offered any free services. Baseline data comes from a nine-page application form, and follow-up surveys were conducted 6, 18, and 60 months after treatment.

Experimental design

Growing America through Entrepreneurship (Project GATE) was an evaluation designed and implemented by the US Department of Labor (DOL) and the US Small Business Administration (SBA). GATE’s objective was to “help emerging entrepreneurs in rural and urban communities achieve the American dream of owning their own business.” The evaluation was designed to capture existing representative training providers and recipients. The treatment phase of the evaluation ran from September 2003 to July 2005 in seven sites that represented both urban and rural areas. Follow-up surveys were mailed 6, 18, and 60 months after random assignment.

Individuals entered the study by completing an application process for a standard offer of free training from 1 of 14 established providers. The application process started with an orientation meeting at 1 of 21 One-Stop Career Centers in the 7 sites. Anyone attending the orientation meeting could then apply by completing and mailing a form with questions on demographics, work and business experience, and the individual’s current business or new business idea. Applicants were informed that “GATE does not have space for everyone” and that a “lottery or random drawing will decide whether you will be able to enter the program.”

Program coordinators randomized applicants to treatment or control with equal probability. Program administrators for each training provider then offered treatment applicants a standard array of free training services, told control applicants that the GATE program did not have the capacity to offer them services, and did not offer control applicants referrals to any other services. Individuals in both treatment and control groups were notified that they would be mailed follow-up surveys. GATE is the largest-ever randomized evaluation of entrepreneurship training and assistance, with 4,197 individuals randomized at baseline.

GATE training providers were chosen with a goal of (not quantitatively determined) representativeness of the subsidized training market. Fourteen organizations from seven different sites participated in the GATE study, with a mix of SBA-funded Small Business Development Centers (SBDCs) and nonprofit community-based organizations (CBOs) in both urban and rural locations. The 14 participating providers deliver services in and around Philadelphia; Pittsburgh; Minneapolis/St. Paul; Duluth, Minnesota; Virginia, Minnesota; Portland, Maine; Lewiston, Maine; and Bangor, Maine. Both types of organizations employ experienced business consultants to deliver one-on-one and group trainings.

99% percent of the treatment group actually received some training during the evaluation horizon, with 81% getting training within 6 months of entering the study. GATE training was customized for the individual from an array of services offered by the provider, as is typical in the subsidized market. Training began with a one-on-one assessment to produce a service plan that typically combined one-on-one services with selected group services. 64% percent of treatment group individuals then received one-on-one counseling/consulting that was customized to the individual’s experience, capabilities, circumstances, and opportunities. 77% percent of the treatment group received classroom/group training(s). These targeted a variety of general and specialized topics at different experience levels. Introductory workshops covered subjects such as legal structure, business plans, and marketing. Intermediate and advanced group trainings covered subjects including managing growth, obtaining financing, legal risks, and personnel issues. More specialized group trainings covered topics such as accounting, information technology, and web-based businesses.

Design details

Randomization method
Not done by authors of the paper, these were publicly available data. see government report, cited in the published academic paper
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
4,197 individuals
Observations
4,197 individuals
Arms
treatment group: 2,094 individuals; control group: 2,103 individuals
Primary outcomes
- Likelihood to produce a business plan - Likelihood of business ownership - Likelihood of business sales - Likelihood of having an employee - Likelihood of creating high-revenue or high-employment firms - Employment - Income - Work satisfaction

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Fairlie, Robert W., Dean Karlan, and Jonathan Zinman. 2015. "Behind the GATE Experiment: Evidence on Effects of and Rationales for Subsidized Entrepreneurship Training." American Economic Journal 7(2): 125-161. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/2605%20effects%20of%20subsidized%20entrepreneurship%20training.pdf

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords