Is family-priority rule the right path? An experimental study of the Chinese organ allocation system
How to cite
Zheng, Heng. 2023. "Is family-priority rule the right path? An experimental study of the Chinese organ allocation system." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012324. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12324-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
China is experiencing an organ shortage crisis.We design a laboratory experiment to study how the family-priority rule affects the willingness to register as a donor as well as the decision of family consent.
Intervention
We experimentally test the effectiveness of the family-priority allocation rule on organ donation and argue that such incentive would be highly motivating in Chinese family-oriented culture.Three different allocation conditions were implemented in the experiment, including the Control condition, the Self-priority condition, and the Family-priority condition. The experiment was performed at the Center for Economic Behavior and Decision-making (CEBD) of Zhejiang University of Finance and Economics in China.16 Subjects were recruited from the college student body through a recruiting program on WeChat that randomly invites registered subjects to participate in the experiment. A total of 720 subjects participated in the experiment .
Experimental design
We adopted the design of Kessler and Roth (2014) as the basic experimental structure. Each subject played the role of a virtual human with one A organ and two B organs in the experiment. Each round of the experiment, each subject was endowed with 8 Chinese Yuan (approximately 1.3 US Dollars) and could earn additional 8 Chinese Yuan if he maintained one active A organ and at least one active B organ at the end of that round. Each round, each subject received a health outcome of either A-organ failure or B-organ failure. If a subject had A-organ failure, he could not earn any more money in that round but could donate his B organs to subjects in need. If a subject had B-organ failure, both of his B organs failed and he could receive a B organ donated by another subject to earn more money in that round.
We modified the design by introducing the concept of family in our experiment. Each session of the experiment contains 16 subjects. Subjects were randomly divided into two fixed groups of 8 players.
Each subject was randomly matched with one subject from another group to form a “family” and the family match stay fixed through the experiment. Family members shared each other’s net gains in each round with a certain ratio to resemble connections between family members in real world.
Three different allocation conditions were implemented in the experiment, including the Control condition, the Self-priority condition, and the Family-priority condition.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.