Long-run effects of welfare reform experiments: Portland and Jobs First

How to cite

Miller, Cynthia; Hoynes, Hilary. 2023. "Long-run effects of welfare reform experiments: Portland and Jobs First." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012321. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12321-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cynthia Miller* , Hilary Hoynes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012321
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12321-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
1993-02-01 – 2025-02-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12321

Abstract

The Learning from Administrative Data (LAD) initiative seeks to extend the evidence of the long-term effects of various welfare-to-work programs evaluated in the 1990s, programs that included components such as earnings supplements, child care subsidies, work requirements,
time limits on benefit receipt, and education services. This study focuses on two programs. The first is Connecticut Jobs First, one of the first welfare reform initiatives to impose statewide time limits on welfare receipt. These time limits were coupled with financial incentives designed to encourage work. The second is the NEWWS program in Portland, which provided employment and support services to a broad cross section of individuals receiving Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC), the prior name for what is now called Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, or TANF. This study will merge data for the study participants with multiple sources of demographic and administrative data in order to assess effects on employment, earnings, fertility, and mortality. The primary focus will be to assess effects on these outcomes during adulthood for individuals who were children during the program period, although effects will also be estimated for selected outcomes for the adult participants.

Intervention

Jobs First represented several changes from the traditional AFDC program in place at the time
of the study. First, Jobs First included a 21-month limit on benefit receipt, after which the
family’s cash grant was discontinued unless an extension or exemption was granted. Under the
existing AFDC program, families did not face any time limits on benefit receipt. Second, Jobs
First included unusually generous financial work incentives, allowing working recipients to
retain their full grant (e.g., disregarding all earned income) until their earnings reach the federal
poverty level. In contrast, AFDC recipients were subject to the standard earned income
disregard (of $120 per month, through month 12 and $90 thereafter). Finally, Jobs First
required recipients to participate in employment-related services targeted towards quick job
placement. Families receiving AFDC, in contrast, were subject to Connecticut’s preexisting
welfare-to-work program, which had broader exemption criteria (for work activities) and a
somewhat stronger focus on education and training.

The NEWWS program in Portland provided employment and support services to a broad cross
section of individuals receiving Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC), the prior name
for what is now called Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, or TANF. As in the other
NEWWS sites, recipients were required to participate in program activities or face reductions in
their welfare grants. The Portland program had a clear employment focus. Unlike the other NEWWS sites, it used a mixed strategy for matching enrollees to initial activities: For more job-ready individuals, they use the same approach as other employment-focused programs by trying to move people into jobs relatively quickly. Case managers, however, had more discretion to assign some people to short-term skill-building activities first. Also, job search participants in Portland, unlike in the other programs, were counseled to wait for a good job (that is, one that paid at least about 25 percent higher than the minimum wage and offered a good chance for stable employment) as opposed to taking the first job they were offered.

Experimental design

Both programs were evaluated using randomized controlled trials.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization conducted by compter.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
4803 adults and 7400 children for Jobs First 5547 adults and 8500 children for Portland
Observations
4803 adults and 7400 children for Jobs First 5547 adults and 8500 children for Portland
Arms
3600 control, 3800 treatment for children in Jobs First 2407 control, 2396 treatment for adults in Jobs First 3100 control, 5400 treatment for children in Portland 2018 control, 3529 treatment for adults in Portland
Primary outcomes
adult earnings of participants' children. examined for each program separately.
Secondary outcomes
Did the programt lead to effects on employment, teen fertility, and mortality in adulthood, for individuals who were children during the study period? 2. Did the program generate long-run impacts on employment, earnings and mortality of adult participants? 3. Did the program generate long-run impacts on participation in government assistance programs (e.g., Medicaid, subsidized housing) among adult participants and their children? 4. Did the program impact geographic mobility and neighborhood characteristics for adult participants and their children? 5. Do the long-term effects vary across subgroups, including groups defined by children’s gender and age at randomization and parents’ employment history, welfare receipt history, and education level? Are the average effects estimated for the full sample similar across the distribution of outcomes, e.g., does the program lead to larger changes in earnings at the bottom of the earnings distribution? 6. Do the long-term effects on earnings and employment of individuals who were children during the study period vary by age in adulthood?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords