Citizens’ Valuation of Urban Afforestation as a Function of the Trade-Offs between CO2 Reduction, Co-Benefits and Land Use Conflicts
How to cite
Bartels, Lara. 2024. "Citizens’ Valuation of Urban Afforestation as a Function of the Trade-Offs between CO2 Reduction, Co-Benefits and Land Use Conflicts." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012316. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12316-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
By 2030, about 60% of the world’s population is projected to live in urban areas. With cities consuming about three-quarters of global natural resources and energy consumption and being responsible for 70% of global CO2 emissions (Gurney et al. 2015; UN-Habitat 2021), they significantly contribute to climate change, but are at the same time most vulnerable to climate change (Rosenzweig et al. 2010). Nature-based solutions such as urban green and blue infrastructures present opportunities for sustainable urbanization, as well as climate mitigation and adaption in urban areas (Martos et al. 2016). Among these, urban forests have the greatest mitigation potential (Lwasa et al. 2022) while also providing substantial co-benefits that facilitate climate adaptation in cities and make living in urban areas more pleasant. Accurately determining the values associated with city trees is crucial for the effectiveness and targeting of tree planting programs (Li 2023) and can ultimately increase a community’s resilience to various climate change-related stresses. To now, there is a limited understanding of the publics' valuation of city trees and the services they provide. To account for this, this study employs a stated choice experiment (CE) to investigate the assessment of diverse urban afforestation programs, aiming to differentiate the values assigned by participants to various aspects of these programs. In particular, the choice experiment enables the differentiation of values attributed by participants to the climate mitigation potential of trees (carbon sequestration) compared to other co-benefits (heat island reduction and increased biodiversity), as well as potential land use conflicts (loss of parking or residential housing space). Therewith, this research fills an important knowledge gap by providing a nuanced understanding of how individuals assess and prioritize diverse aspects of urban afforestation programs. The findings will help to inform sustainable urban planning strategies that balance climate change mitigation, environmental benefits, and potential drawbacks, ultimately leading to more effective and socially acceptable urban afforestation programs.
Intervention
The objective of this study is to conduct a stated choice experiment to understand the valuation of urban afforestation of German citizens. Specifically, I aim to identify the relative importance of different attributes of urban afforestation, such as the co-benefits of urban trees, land conflicts, location of tree, and carbon sequestration potential and aim to i) identify the attributes of urban afforestation that are most important to urban residents, ii) estimate the economic values that urban residents attach to these attributes, and iii) explore how demographic and socio-economic factors as well as locational variables (i.e. the tree population of the neighborhood) influence choices and can help explain taste heterogeneities.
Study participants will be invited to answer a survey on city climate mitigation and adoption that also included a stated choice experiment on urban afforestation. The survey is structured in four main parts: (i) general introduction with some pre-experimental questions, (ii) introduction to the choice context with some behavioral, context-related questions, (iii) the choice experiment tasks and follow-up questions to the tasks, and (iv) socio-demographic questions. Within the choice experiment, each participants answers six choice sets in which respondents are asked to choose among three alternatives, i.e., two urban afforestation measures (alternative 1 and 2) and a status quo option.
Experimental design
I am employing a discrete choice experiment within an online survey to evaluate the valuation of urban afforestation by citizens of a major German city. The survey will be administered by the survey institute Bilendi to a specifically chosen group of participants from their panel database, with a target of 1,000 responses. Participants will be notified about the survey via email, with the added incentive of earning points that can be exchanged for vouchers, cash, or donations.
The sample is restricted to individuals residing in Berlin, ensuring a representative distribution in terms of gender, education (high vs. medium/low), and age to reflect the demographics of the German population.
The final data collection is scheduled for February 2024. A pre-test was conducted in November 2023 with a broader population sample of approximately 260 participants. For the pre-test, a d-efficient design was generated using the Stata command "dcreate" for a multinomial logit model with zero priors for main effects. The priors obtained from the pre-test were subsequently used to estimate a final d-efficient design. The ultimate choice experiment comprises 150 choice sets distributed across 25 blocks. Individuals are randomly assigned to one of the 25 blocks and answer the included six choice sets in a random order.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.