AI or human? Applicants’ decisions in discrimination settings
How to cite
Scholz, Paula; Wolf, Luisa Santiago; Stommel, David. 2023. "AI or human? Applicants’ decisions in discrimination settings." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012308. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12308-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While there is agreement on the great potential for efficiencies and savings that the use of artificial intelligence (AI) can bring to recruitment, there is also an ongoing debate about the ethical and legal implications of hiring algorithms. The existing literature on the perception of hiring algorithms is ambiguous. Therefore, we investigate the question whether anticipated discrimination influences applicants’ preferences for a hiring algorithm. We conduct an online experiment based on the design of Dargnies et al. (2022) in which applicants are asked to decide whether a human manager or an AI should take their hiring decision. The novelty in our approach is the simulation of discrimination settings. We distinguish between taste-based and statistical discrimination. Using artificially formed groups, we can address a wide range of characteristics on which grounds candidates can be discriminated against. Our findings therefore extend to a broad group of applicants. The results of our study contribute to a better understanding of the potential of AI-assisted hiring processes, which can help to attract more diverse groups of applicants.
Intervention
The laboratory experiment investigates whether the potential of discrimination influences applicants’ preferences for a hiring algorithm.
To this end, applicants can choose to be hired by a human manager or by an artificial intelligence in different hiring situations which entail the potential of discrimination.
Experimental design
The experiment will be conducted via Prolific.
We conduct an online experiment based on the design of Dargnies et al. (2022). In the experiment, participants are assigned either the role of applicants or managers. Applicants perform two work sample tasks and one job task. Managers and the algorithm receive the work sample task performance of a worker pair of similar work sample task performance and decide whom to hire based on this. Before the hiring decision, both the manager and the algorithm receive a random subset of workers’ work sample and job task performance data as a training set. Applicants are informed about the training opportunity and how the algorithm and the manager take the hiring decision. Applicants are asked to decide whether a human manager or an artificial intelligence should take their hiring decision.
The novelty in our study is the stimulation of anticipated discrimination. Following standard approaches to labor market discrimination, we distinguish between taste-based and statistical discrimination. The perceived potential for discrimination is achieved using minimal groups based on colors as well as training opportunities for applicants.
Further survey evidence as well as beliefs about other participants’ actions and performances are elicited at the end of the experiment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.