Discrimination in labor markets of Ecuador, Colombia, Perú, Bolivia, and Paraguay: field experiments

How to cite

Zanoni, Wladimir; Duryea, Suzanne. 2023. "Discrimination in labor markets of Ecuador, Colombia, Perú, Bolivia, and Paraguay: field experiments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012295. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12295-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Wladimir Zanoni* , Suzanne Duryea

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012295
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12295-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-10-15 – 2024-02-28
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J7; J15; J16; J21; J61; J14; F22; R38
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12295

Abstract

This study is a comprehensive research initiative to 1) quantify discrimination against diverse and vulnerable groups in the labor market in Latin American countries; and 2) test the effectiveness of behavioral interventions to reduce discrimination. The primary methodology employed is field experiments, specifically "vignette studies," as described in the literature on experimental field economics. This approach has been previously applied by the researchers in this team:

1) Conceptual and Methodological Note to Measure Discrimination Against Slum Dwellers and the Impact on Discrimination of Slum Upgrading Interventions: Case Study of Buenos Aires (2020) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0002907
2) Job Market Discrimination against Slum Dwellers in Urban Argentina (2022) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004179
3) Hacia una nueva metodología para conducir experimentos de campo para el estudio de la discriminación: el caso de los migrantes en el mercado inmobiliario colombiano (2022) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004467
4) Discrimination Against Workers From Slums: What Is its Extent, What Explains It, and How Do We Tackle It? (2023) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004799
5) Discrimination Against Migrants and its Determinants Evidence from a Multi-Purpose Field Experiment in the Housing Rental Market (2023) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0004803
6) Measuring Labor Market Discrimination against LGTBQ+ in the Case of Ecuador: A Field Experiment (2023) http://dx.doi.org/10.18235/0005026

The current study aims to measure discrimination and evaluate public policy options within the labor markets of Bolivia, Colombia, Perú, Paraguay, and Ecuador. The focus is on specific vulnerable populations:

In Bolivia, the study targets individuals with physical disabilities, rural-urban migrants, and transgender people.
In Colombia and Perú, the emphasis is on migrants and those with physical disabilities.
Paraguay's study centers on individuals with physical disabilities, women, and another yet-to-be-defined population.
Ecuador's research is on Venezuelan migrants, individuals with physical disabilities, and women.

The study is structured into several phases, all of which will be conducted in Bolivia, Colombia, Perú, Paraguay, and Ecuador:

Experimental Design Phase: This involves creating a virtual platform for participants who will be Human Resource Recruiters whom we will hire to conduct an experiment. Through this platform, they will replicate the selection processes for job applications associated with various job vacancies.
Experimental Implementation Phase: Data on recruiters' sociodemographic profiles and cognitive-socioemotional characteristics are collected. Recruiters will evaluate synthetic profiles of job applicants using the platform.
Results Analysis Phase: Data is compiled to study recruiters' responses. The findings will then be disseminated to inform public policymakers.

Experimental design

Research Design and Collaboration with a Consulting Firm:
In our upcoming research spanning five countries (Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, and Paraguay), we intend to partner with a consulting firm that has a physical presence in each of these nations. This firm will be instrumental in implementing our field experiment, given its local expertise and understanding of the diverse labor markets.

Recruitment of Human Resource Recruiters:
We will hire experienced human resource recruiters from the labor markets of each country. To ensure genuine engagement and commitment, the recruitment process will be presented as a real job-hiring exercise. Our strategy to source these recruiters will involve respondent-driven sampling (RDS) referrals and LinkedIn and other media platforms job postings. To acknowledge their expertise and time, recruiters will be compensated competitively, which will also enhance the credibility and impact of our study.

Gathering Preliminary Insights:
To inform our experimental design, we plan to conduct interviews and focus groups with key stakeholders in each country. This will include recruitment agencies, independent agents, LGBTQ+ migrants and women workers, and labor market experts in academia and governments. The insights and feedback from these interactions will be pivotal in tailoring our experiment to closely resemble the authentic job market settings in the respective countries.

Creation of Synthetic Job Applicant Profiles:
We aim to create a controlled experimental environment that mirrors the real-world job application process. To achieve this, we will design synthetic resumes that are representative of actual job applications in the formal labor markets of the five countries. These profiles will be comparable in qualifications and attributes, with the only distinction being the self-identification as a minority for some candidates. This approach will allow us to isolate and measure the potential impact of minority identity on recruiters' evaluations.

Experimental Trials:
Our experiment will consist of up to ten trials per human resources recruiter hired in each country. In some trials, an applicant will be randomly assigned to disclose their minority membership, while others will not. We will also include trials comparing different genders, migrants versus locals, and placebo trials with no distinguishable prejudiced attributes. This design will enable us to explore discriminatory behaviors in various contexts, while also masking the primary research objective.

Development of an Online Platform:
To efficiently conduct our experiment, we will develop a custom web platform tailored to our study's requirements. This platform will serve as the interface for presenting candidates to the recruiters and collecting their evaluations. It will be designed to ensure a seamless experience for the recruiters, while also maintaining the integrity and confidentiality of the experiment.

Recruiter Onboarding and Data Collection:
All participating recruiters will be required to register on our online platform. We will collect information on their socioeconomic background, education, work experience, and knowledge of the local labor market. To gain deeper insights into their evaluation process, we will track metrics like the time spent reviewing applications and their activity on the platform. After registration, recruiters will be presented with job vacancies and corresponding candidate profiles to evaluate.

Design details

Randomization method
A random number will be assigned to job applicant candidates within each evaluation set (or trial of the experiment); the online platform will use that random number to assign a minority condition to one of the individuals in each set.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization are the simulated job applicants
Clusters
350 per country
Observations
1750 recruiters across all countries
Arms
150-200 treated with nudge 1; 150-200 treated with nudge 2; 150-200 untreated
Primary outcomes
Probability of selecting a minority candidate; Differences in wages offered between a minority and a non-minority candidate; Differences in fit for the job assessments between minority and non-minority job applicants.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords