Refugee and Host Integration through the Safety Net Impact Evaluation

How to cite

Rozo, Sandra; Egger, Dennis; Abebe, Girum; Manfredini, Alfredo; Wieser, Christina. 2023. "Refugee and Host Integration through the Safety Net Impact Evaluation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012288. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12288-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sandra Rozo* , Dennis Egger , Girum Abebe , Alfredo Manfredini , Christina Wieser

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012288
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12288-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-10-01 – 2028-10-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H4, J61, O1
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12288

Abstract

This research project examines the impacts of integrating refugees into a national public works and livelihoods program. It leverages a nationwide large-scale randomized controlled trial conducted among 22,500 households across six refugee camps and neighboring areas in Ethiopia. The program under investigation, called Refugee and Host Integration through the Safety Net (RHISN), offers remunerated participation in public works (e.g. building roads, irrigation ditches, cleaning public spaces, etc.), business trainings and coaching, and a USD 600 business grant to refugee and host beneficiaries to promote economic livelihoods and socio-economic integration between refugees and hosts through joint work in integrated teams. We will assess i) whether the program improves beneficiaries’ well-being (including economic, social, and psychological well-being), ii) the productivity and social cohesion effects of inter-group contact by mixing refugees and hosts in public works groups, and iv) the economic and social spillover effects of the program. This is one of the first Sub-Saharan efforts to integrate refugees into a national social protection system. Our findings will inform the ongoing shift of policy in the region from a primarily camp-based humanitarian approach to one based on promoting socio-economic integration.

Intervention

This research project will examine the impacts of the Refugee and Host Integration through the Safety Net program (RHISN). RHISN is implemented by the Government of Ethiopia through the Ministry of Urban and Infrastructure and the Refugees and Returnees Service, is one of few attempts by a LMIC to integrate camp-based refugees into the national social safety net. Refugees and hosts alike will participate in remunerated public works activities (e.g. building water points, roads, irrigation ditches, etc.) for up to 3 years providing a stable source of income. In addition, beneficiaries will receive graduation-style livelihood support consisting of training, and a 600 USD business grant in the second year. Beneficiaries will also obtain a work permit to legally participate in the local host labor market. As such, RHISN represents a unique opportunity to study the consequences of integrating refugees into a graduation program through experimental variation at scale. Its large-scale nature will allow us to study not only direct impacts on recipients, but also impacts on non-recipients, on local economic activity, on social cohesion at the neighborhood and work-team level, and the channels that underlie them.

Together with the Ethiopian government, we have set up a large-scale Randomized Control Trial (RCT) among the four main refugee hosting areas in Ethiopia with over 20,000 beneficiaries to evaluate the scaled-up implementation of RHISN. Baseline social integration varies widely across these areas, ranging from places where hosts and refugees share a common language, religion and tribal affiliation to others where they do not share any, and where there is sporadic violent conflict. Experimental work in this space is limited because conducting RCTs in humanitarian settings is complicated by the high vulnerability and mobility of forcibly displaced populations. Even rarer are studies using randomization at-scale which is crucial to understanding both the implementation challenges of large programs, as well as the general equilibrium (or economy-wide) forces shaping economic and social integration dynamics, and for generalizing findings to other contexts. Our proposed project has both elements.

Experimental design

We will study the above-mentioned questions through a large-scale clustered RCT conducted among four refugee camps and nearby host populations across all major refugee hosting regions of Ethiopia with a total of 22,500 beneficiaries. All refugees who express interest are eligible. Among host populations, eligibility is determined through a baseline proxy-means test (PMT). Due to ethical considerations on the vulnerability of applicants, 37% of the beneficiary quota is assigned automatically to the poorest households according to the PMT. 63% of the quota is assigned randomly among the remaining vulnerable households.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer randomization
Randomization unit
We will randomize the following aspects of the program: T1 – Participation in RHISN: Eligible host community and refugee households are randomly selected into 3-year participation in remunerated public works, a legal work permit, livelihoods training and USD 600 business grants. T2 – Contact through mixed refugee/host work teams: RHISN beneficiaries will be randomly assigned to public work groups. Work groups consist of ~30 individuals who work together on public projects for the first year and attend livelihood training together in the second year. There are 3 types of groups: ‘Refugee/host only groups’ are constituted only of the in-group. ‘Equal groups’ have 15 refugee and 15 host members; and ‘refugee minority groups’ are approximately 20 hosts and 10 refugees. T3 – Social cohesion activities: A random subset of public work groups will be invited (by a partner NGO) to attend monthly teas and dinners, and an annual cultural festival promoting after-work socializing. T4 – Local program saturation: We randomly vary the saturation of a) the program overall, and b) the extent of outgroup exposure within small geographic areas. Host communities are administratively organized into ketenas (neighborhoods) of approx. 200 households each. On the refugee side, an equivalent administrative unit is the block group (250 households each). There are 83 ketenas and 97 block groups, or a total of 180 clusters in our study area. We cross randomize at the cluster level in two dimensions. A: We randomize the intensity of program saturation: In high-saturation clusters, ⅔ of eligible households will be treated, in low saturation clusters ⅓. This induces random variation in program intensity across neighborhoods/clusters and allows us to estimate economic spillover effects of the program on non-recipients, and on the aggregate economy. B: We cross-randomize the intensity of outgroup contact: In high-exposure neighborhoods/clusters, 2/3 of RHISN beneficiaries are assigned to mixed groups, while in low-exposure clusters only 1/3 are mixed. We cross-randomize this with program saturation to be able to separately estimate social spillovers of outgroup contact.
Clusters
180
Observations
12,000
Arms
Sample treatment: 8,000 Sample control: 4,000 We have multiple levels of randomization across groups to answer the pre-specified research questions.
Primary outcomes
Primary research questions 1- What are the impacts RHISN on the wellbeing of the program’s beneficiaries? Outcomes: household income, consumption, assets, labor outcomes, and mental health. 2- What are the impacts of team diversity and inter-group contact on productivity and social cohesion? Outcomes: social cohesion between refugees and hosts, network formation, team productivity. 3- What are the spillover effects of the program on local economic aggregates and social cohesion? Outcomes: prices, wages, product diversity, local economic activity, GDP; neighborhood-level social cohesion, out-group attitudes, economic integration.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary research questions: 4- How do the impacts of diversity on team dynamics, task allocation, communication, and productivity vary by the share of outgroup members in the work team? 5- Does additional after-work socializing (teas, dinners, cultural festivals) amplify the impacts of outgroup contact? 6- How do social norms, attitudes towards the outgroup, and social cohesion propagate through existing social and economic networks? 7- How do public good improvements impacts social cohesion and well-being?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords