Access, use, and welfare effect of crowdsourced agricultural information: Evidence from Kenya

How to cite

Shikuku, Kelvin Mashisia; Lepariyo, Watson; Alulu, Vincent. 2023. "Access, use, and welfare effect of crowdsourced agricultural information: Evidence from Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012282. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12282-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kelvin Mashisia Shikuku* , Watson Lepariyo , Vincent Alulu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012282
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12282-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-01 – 2024-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D81, D83, I31, O33, Q13, Q16, Q54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12282

Abstract

Crowdsourcing is increasingly utilized for the collection of agricultural information in remote and fragile contexts. Agricultural information crowdsourcing initiatives can influence decision making and behavior. Recent efforts use such initiatives to dynamically monitor shocks and inform early warning and anticipatory action. The relevance of such information depends on the ability to reach the target audience (in our case, the pastoralists) in a timely manner. This requires dissemination of the information. While there has been considerable effort to collect crowdsourced information, very little attention has been placed on its dissemination for decision making. Therefore, knowledge on the access, use, and effect of such information is inadequate. This knowledge gap makes it difficult to conclude whether and the extent to which agricultural information crowdsourcing initiatives are beneficial. This study, implemented within a pastoralist setting, attempts to fill this gap by conducting a cluster-randomized controlled trial (cluster RCT) to assess access and use of livestock information collected via the KAZNET initiative. The study further assesses the welfare effects of the KAZNET livestock information crowdsourcing initiative and probes the mechanisms through which such effects occur. The RCT randomizes 200 villages into one treatment arm and one control arm. The treatment arm is assigned to receive KAZNET livestock information via a mobile phone dashboard. The control arm is not signed up to receive KAZNET livestock information. Within each village, we target pastoralist groups/associations for the KAZNET livestock information diffusion.

Intervention

The study design is a cluster-randomized controlled trial. We will randomize 200 villages into one treatment arm and one control. We will work with 24 “contributors” to sign-up the treatment arm for crowdsourced KAZNET information about the performance of livestock markets, rangeland conditions, livestock mortality and the associated causes, and milk production. The target sample includes pastoralists groups within the selected villages. We will use a minimum distance rule for the selection of villages; for example, any two villages in the sample must be a minimum of 5 km apart. While we cannot rule out that people who live in different villages may still talk to each other, imposing a minimum distance reduces the likelihood that people will belong to more than one group in our sample or observe the behavior or practices of those in another village. All pastoralist groups in a village belong to either the treatment arm (T1) or control (T0). In each pastoralist group, five individuals will be recruited into the study. In the treatment arm, the KAZNET crowdsourcing approach will be explained. Pastoralists will be informed about the process of data collection and the information that is available for dissemination. Individuals with smartphones will be asked if they would be willing to sign-up to receive information on their smartphones. Those expressing interest will be registered on the KAZNET app for information access. Pastoralist groups in the control villages will not receive any information about KAZNET and will not be provided the opportunity to sign-up for KAZNET information.

Experimental design

The study design is a cluster-randomized controlled trial. We will randomize 200 villages into one treatment arm and one control. We will work with 24 “contributors” to sign-up the treatment arm for crowdsourced KAZNET information about the performance of livestock markets, rangeland conditions, livestock mortality and the associated causes, and milk production. The target sample includes pastoralists groups within the selected villages. We will use a minimum distance rule for the selection of villages; for example, any two villages in the sample must be a minimum of 5 km apart. While we cannot rule out that people who live in different villages may still talk to each other, imposing a minimum distance reduces the likelihood that people will belong to more than one group in our sample or observe the behaviour or practices of those in another village. All pastoralist groups in a village belong to either the treatment arm (T1) or control (T0). In each pastoralist group, five individuals will be recruited into the study. In the treatment arm, the KAZNET crowdsourcing approach will be explained. Pastoralists will be informed about the process of data collection and the information that is available for dissemination. Individuals with smartphones will be asked if they would be willing to sign-up to receive information on their smartphones. Those expressing interest will be registered on the KAZNET app for information access. Pastoralist groups in the control villages will not receive any information about KAZNET and will not be provided the opportunity to sign-up for KAZNET information.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in the office by a computer using a replicable stata code.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization are villages.
Clusters
200 villages
Observations
2,000 pastoralists.
Arms
100 villages control and another 100 villages treatment (i.e., receive KAZNET crowdsourced livestock information)
Primary outcomes
Our main outcome variables measure (1) household dietary diversity score, (2) months of food self-sufficiency, and (3) reduced coping strategy index.
Secondary outcomes
KAZNET was mentioned as a source of information on livestock markets and forage conditions, perceived usefulness of KAZNET information, trust in KAZNET data, number of people with whom the respondent discusses about markets and forage conditions, changing selling markets, selling livestock in markets with better prices, and purchasing and storing fodder, price knowledge, we look at the ability or willingness to report a price by livestock type and market, inputs expenditure, livestock selling price, livestock mortality, and income.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords