Do citizens change their beliefs, participation and satisfaction upon learning about state performance? An RCT in India
How to cite
Prabhakar, Pallavi; Kishore, Diwakar. 2024. "Do citizens change their beliefs, participation and satisfaction upon learning about state performance? An RCT in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012281. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12281-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Successful inclusive growth policies in low and middle-income countries require effective performance by local governments. Arguably, an important reason for poor state performance is that citizens have limited information about state performance and are therefore unable to hold local governments to account. Correspondingly, we expect that citizens with greater information about state performance are more likely to demand accountability from the state. Using a Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT) that creates exogenous variation in incentivized beliefs about the performance of the state for 2100 respondents in Jharkhand, India, we test whether providing information to citizens about the service performance of their district leads to them changing their beliefs about state performance, participation with the government and satisfaction with public service delivery. Our study contributes new findings to research about on political accountability, the drivers of economic development, inequality, and governance.
Intervention
The intervention for the study entails presenting participants with a comprehensive 7-minute video as part of the survey. This video delves into Ranchi's performance within the framework of the Aspirational Districts Programme, with a specific focus on the domains of health, education, and infrastructure. The video places particular emphasis on three pivotal indicators extracted from the Champions of Change Dashboard: the percentage of underweight children under the age of 6, adherence to the Pupil Teacher Ratio mandated by the Right To Education Act in elementary schools, and the proportion of habitations with access to all-weather roads under the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY).
Furthermore, this video incorporates a comparative analysis, contrasting Ranchi's performance with that of five neighboring districts, thereby offering a relative assessment of each indicator. The intervention also highlights the significance of the "Champions of Change Dashboard" as an indispensable tool for monitoring and evaluating developmental progress. It goes a step further by educating participants about the various channels available for lodging grievances or expressing concerns to the government. These include prominent platforms such as CPGRAMS, the Meri Sadak Application, and the Right to Information Act, serving to promote civic awareness and encourage active participation in governance processes.
Experimental design
This research employs an Individual Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) with a sample size of 2,100 participants, stratified by gender. These participants are drawn from rural Ranchi, an aspirational district in Jharkhand, and are randomly allocated into two groups: the Treatment group (n=1050) and the Control group (n=1050).
Treatment Group: Information - Participants in the treatment group will receive information through an informative video. This video will provide insights into their district's average absolute performance on pre-selected indicators assessed under the Aspirational Districts Program (ADP). Additionally, they will gain an understanding of how their district compares to five neighboring districts in terms of average performance. The video will also introduce participants to the Aspirational Districts Program and the "Champions of Change Dashboard," which serves as an open platform for citizens to regularly monitor their district's progress. Beyond government performance, this video will also offer guidance on citizens' rights and government initiatives, enabling them to actively engage in demanding improved public service delivery.
Control Group: Placebo Video - Conversely, the control group will watch a placebo video, unrelated to state performance or citizen engagement. This video will serve the purpose of keeping respondents engaged during the time frame in which the treatment group receives information about government performance. Specifically, it will be a historical documentary focused on the archaeological discovery of an ancient town in Rajasthan (a different state from Jharkhand).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.