The effect of self-confidence and expectations on performance

How to cite

Nikolov, Plamen. 2016. "The effect of self-confidence and expectations on performance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001228. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1228-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Plamen Nikolov*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001228
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1228-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-05-01 – 2017-04-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1228

Abstract

There is ample evidence that emotions affect performance. Positive emotions can improve performance, while negative ones can diminish it. For example, the fears induced by the possibility of failure or of negative evaluations have physiological consequences (shaking, loss of concentration) that may impair performance in sports, on stage, or at school. There is also ample evidence that individuals have distorted recollection of past events and distorted attributions of the causes of success or failure. Recollection of good events or successes is typically easier than recollection of bad ones or failures. Successes tend to be attributed to intrinsic aptitudes or effort, while failures are attributed to bad luck. In addition, these attributions are often reversed when judging the performance of others.

Compte and Postlewaite (2004) incorporate the phenomenon that emotions affect performance into an otherwise standard decision theoretic model and show that in a world where performance depends on emotions, biases in information processing enhance welfare.

We test their empirical predictions of the Compte and Postlewaite (2004) model using the study design described below.

Intervention

In two subsequent sessions, subjects will be given a task to solve within 30-min.

Each subject will be randomized into five treatment groups as described:

Task Target: High or Low
Piecemeal Rate (for bonus/penalty if target not reached): High or Low
Control group

Each subject’s pay will be based on the following function:

Subject’s pay = Task performance + Target performance

● Instructions for Phase 1 will be given. Instructions will highlight the sample tasks, examples and opportunity for subjects to ask any questions.
● Phase 1: We elicit for all subjects a proxy for “confidence” level regarding their performance on the tasks.
○ Then, subjects perform a task within a 30-min timeframe. Their task is scored and given an objective score.
○ Throughout 30-min session, targets will be announced to subjects every 5 minutes.
○ We elicit subject’s subjective assessment of performance from Phase 1; We elicit brief measure of “confidence” and “concentration”
● Phase 2: Subjects perform the task again within a 30-min timeframe
● Phase 3: We administer a short survey collecting socio-economic and risk-preference elicitation, subject’s subjective assessment of performance from Phase 1 and 2.

We will study the effect of treatment group randomization on task performance in Phase 2.

Experimental design

In two subsequent sessions, subjects will be given a task to solve within 30-min.

Each subject will be randomized into five treatment groups as described:

Task Target: High or Low
Piecemeal Rate (for bonus/penalty if target not reached): High or Low
Control group

Each subject’s pay will be based on the following function:

Subject’s pay = Task performance + Target performance

● Instructions for Phase 1 will be given. Instructions will highlight the sample tasks, examples and opportunity for subjects to ask any questions.
● Phase 1: We elicit for all subjects a proxy for “confidence” level regarding their performance on the tasks.
○ Then, subjects perform a task within a 30-min timeframe. Their task is scored and given an objective score.
○ Throughout 30-min session, targets will be announced to subjects every 5 minutes.
○ We elicit subject’s subjective assessment of performance from Phase 1; We elicit brief measure of “confidence” and “concentration”
● Phase 2: Subjects perform the task again within a 30-min timeframe
● Phase 3: We administer a short survey collecting socio-economic and risk-preference elicitation, subject’s subjective assessment of performance from Phase 1 and 2.

We will study the effect of treatment group randomization on task performance in Phase 2.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
500 subjects
Observations
500
Arms
500
Primary outcomes
Labor productivity, Task performance

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords