Reducing the digital divide for marginalized households

How to cite

Tommasi, Denni; Barone, Guglielmo; Loviglio, Annalisa. 2024. "Reducing the digital divide for marginalized households." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012259. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12259-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Denni Tommasi* , Guglielmo Barone , Annalisa Loviglio

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012259
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12259-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-05 – 2025-06-30
Countries
Italy (Turin)
JEL codes
I21, O15, O33, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12259

Abstract

Our study aims to address a critical challenge in contemporary society: the integration of low-income families into the rapidly growing digital society. We implement and evaluate a program designed to achieve this goal through three primary channels. Firstly, it ensures families' access to internet connectivity. Secondly, it provides them with digital devices, thus reducing economic barriers to technology adoption. Finally, it fosters the development of digital skills among family members, enabling them to effectively utilize available digital resources.
The program is implemented in an Italian city and involves approximately 900 participants, assigned to two treatment groups and a control group. We anticipate that implementing this intervention will promote increased online participation among treated families, enhancing their ability to access digital services, resources, and opportunities. We believe that sustainable digital access will encourage consistent and long-term engagement in the digital society, leading to improved quality of life for these families. This, in turn, should positively impact their job-seeking efforts, interactions with public services, and the education of their children.

Intervention

The intervention focuses on low-income families with school-age children, aiming to enhance their digital access and skills through a program that provides tablets, a year of free internet, and digital training for one adult per family. In collaboration with an Italian ONG, we implemented a RCT allocating over 850 applicants into a control and two treatment groups.

All treated individuals receive tablets and internet access for a year. The two treatment groups differ in duration and content of the training. In fact, all courses cover basic digital skills, and the second treatment includes additional specialized topics. Applicants filled the baseline survey between September and November 2023, the application outcomes were disclosed in November 2023, followed by information sessions in December for the treated. Courses began in January 2024, running once a week for two hours, concluding in April for one treatment harm and May for the other. Throughout the program, participation is monitored, culminating in a final test during the last class.

A follow-up in October 2024, approximately one year after the baseline survey, will revisit applicants with the same questions from the baseline, along with inquiries about changes in digital competencies, work attitude, and digital activities conducted with their children.

Experimental design

We received approximately 859 valid applications, each indicating participant's preferred class locations and time slots. Our experimental design is based on block randomization (stratification) at the individual level. We randomize participants to one of three treatment statuses - Control (C), Treatment 1 (T1), and Treatment 2 (T2). 522 applicants are allocated to treatment (261 to each treatment group) and the remaining 337 to control. We use five dichotomous variables for stratification, which means that we have 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 = 32 strata. We group participants into classes based on class location and time slot preferences.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office using Stata
Randomization unit
participant
Clusters
102 classes
Observations
859
Arms
- 25 classes (261 eligible individuals) in treatment 1 - 26 classes (261 eligible individuals) in treatment 2 - 51 classes (337 eligible individuals) in control
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes are the variables targeted by the training. These outcomes are evaluated in October/November 2024, roughly 6 months after the training, in comparison to baseline measurements collected in October/November 2023, 12 months prior. We categorize our primary outcomes as "short-term." They are divided into five sets of categories: 1) Adoption: This category focuses on assessing whether participants are adopting the provided device and internet connection. 2) Digital literacy: This category aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the training program in enhancing participants' digital literacy skills. We use an index derived from Eurostat, comprising five sub-indices. 3) Social inclusion: This category focuses on assessing whether participants have taken steps towards improving their socio-economic status, particularly whether participants searched for or requested income measures against poverty. 4) Human capital transmission: This is assessed through a series of questions, partially derived from PISA, focusing on parents' engagement in activities related to their children's education. 5) Labor market: This category assesses participants' readiness for and engagement with the labor market, focusing on their attitudes, motivations, and efforts related to employment.
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes are the variables targeted by the training beyond the 10-month period. We categorize them as "long-term." They are "secondary" for us because it is less likely that we have the power to observe the program's effects on them directly and because we need to request access to Italian administrative data to study them. These outcomes are divided into three sets of categories: 1) Social inclusion: The variables are constructed based on whether participants obtained and benefited from income measures targeted at reducing poverty. 2) Human capital transmission: This category focuses on evaluating the long-term effect of the intervention on the educational outcomes of the participants' children. 3) Labor market: This category evaluates the long-term impact of the training program on participants' labor market outcomes, including their employment status, wages, and engagement with employment services.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords