Identifying management skill

How to cite

Vecci, Joe; Weidmann, Ben; Bhalotra, Sonia; Deming, David; Said, Farah. 2023. "Identifying management skill." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012258. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12258-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joe Vecci* , Ben Weidmann , Sonia Bhalotra , David Deming , Farah Said

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012258
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12258-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-10-26 – 2023-12-17
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
JEL codes
C92, J01
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12258

Abstract

Effective managers play a vital role in successful teams by creating a positive and productive team environment, assigning tasks, setting clear goals and expectations, and facilitating communication and collaboration among team members. In this paper, we employ a distinctive experimental design to identify the marginal advantage of effective managers, and the specific attributes that yield the greatest benefits to team performance. Despite the increasing importance of teamwork in the modern workplace, there is limited experimental research exploring the added value of managers in raising team productivity.

Intervention

Sessions will be randomly assigned to one of two conditions.

Experimental design

NA

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will take place via computer. There are two levels of randomization: - Randomization of sessions to treatment or control and - Randomization of groups. We explain each in turn. Randomization of Role Assignment Mechanism We randomly allocate each session to either be a ‘self selection’ or ‘no choice’ treatment. Sessions will be equally split across these conditions, as we will use pair randomization. Pairs will be sessions that are closest together in time. Randomization of Groups To run a study ‘session’ there must be at least n=12 participants. Ideally, there will be n=15 participants at a time. Workers are randomly assigned to managers, with two constraints: if possible, we do not consider groupings in which workers are allocated to a manager they have worked with before. Second, workers are allocated to a manager at most once (e.g., when n=15, they are allocated to each manager at most once). See detailed analysis plan for further details. The ordering in which groups are matched to managers are randomized. When the number of participants who show up to a session is not divisible by 3, we randomly select participants to withdraw until we have the correct number. Participants who are withdrawn are paid an appearance fee for their time.
Randomization unit
The ‘role selection’ treatment will be randomized at the session level so that each session only contains a single treatment or control. Within each sessions subjects will be randomized into groups of three. This re-randomization of groups occurs five times following the procedure outlined in detail in the Appendix.
Clusters
We plan to conduct around 30 sessions.
Observations
We plan to conduct the experiment until we reach 402 individual subjects. As we aim for each session to contain a maximum of 15 subjects (and, may contain as few as 12) we expect we will need around 30 sessions. However, we will conduct further/less sessions until we reach our goal of 402 individual subjects.
Arms
We plan to split sessions equally between the ‘self selection’ and ‘no choice’ arms. We aim to conduct around 15 no choice sessions and 15 self selection sessions, which will consist of approximately 201 subjects in each arm.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome of interest is how well groups perform on a novel ‘allocation task’. Specifically, we are primarily interested in group performance conditional on the individual task-specific skills of their group members. Our proposed analysis and framework is described in Section 3 of the detailed analysis plan. The detailed analysis plan also includes a description of the group allocation task.
Secondary outcomes
NA

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords