Prior studies suggest that when acting as spectators people attach normative significance to a decision-maker making a choice, even when every choice in the set of alternatives available to the decision-maker generates identical probabilistic outcomes. Our study is designed to understand the potential factors that drive this finding and examine its robustness.
Intervention
We investigate whether spectators attach moral significance to stakeholders having the opportunity to make a choice even when every alternative in the choice set generates identical probabilistic outcomes. We will conduct an online experiment via a Qualtrics survey distributed through Prolific. Our design draws upon Cappelen et al. (2022) and contains a total of six treatment arms. Further details are provided in the pre analysis plan.
Experimental design
Please see the pre-analysis plan for details.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization features in Qualtrics and Prolific
Randomization unit
Prolific’s demographic balancing feature will be used to achieve a 50/50 split between male and female participants aged 18-65.
Clusters
1,440 subjects (6 treatment arms X 240 subjects per treatment arm).
Observations
1,440 subjects (6 treatment arms X 240 subjects per treatment arm).
Arms
The planned sample size is 1,440 (6 treatment arms X 240 subjects per treatment arm). In each treatment arm, 40 subjects will be in the role of stakeholders. This will result in 20 pairs of stakeholders in each treatment arm. The remaining 200 subjects in a treatment arm will be in the role of spectators. Ten distinct spectators will be matched with one pair of stakeholders.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variable of interest is the transfer decision made by spectators across the six treatment arms. Please see the pre-analysis plan for details.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome variables of interest are views of spectators and stakeholders about
(a) whether stakeholders have a meaningful choice;
(b) whether stakeholders have meaningful control over their earnings;
(c) whether the inequality in realized earnings across stakeholders is entirely due to luck; and,
(d) modal transfer decision by spectators.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.