Evaluation of the Social Support for Resilient Livelihoods Project in Malawi
How to cite
Mwale, Martin; Lerva, Benedetta; Beam, Emily. 2023. "Evaluation of the Social Support for Resilient Livelihoods Project in Malawi." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012246. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12246-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We measure the impact of a large-scale, multi-faceted social protection program, the Social Support for Resilience Livelihoods Project (SSRLP) in Malawi, a government-led initiative implemented by the Community Savings and Investment Promotion (COMSIP). Using two distinct randomized controlled trials, we assess the effects of various livelihood support packages on households participating in either the government's Social Cash Transfer (SCT) program or the Climate-Smart Enhanced Public Works Program (CSEPWP). In Experiment 1, Savings and Loan Group clusters that have successfully completed a series of basic trainings are randomized to receive no additional support or one of three program versions: an "enhanced" program that includes skill training and a seed input subsidy; a "graduation" program with coaching, livelihood training, and an asset transfer; or both. In Experiment 2, we measure the impact of one element of the "enhanced" program—the Youth Skills Challenge (YSC)—which provides training and an asset transfer to support livelihood development—by randomly assigning top applicants to a treatment or control group. We evaluate the impacts of these sets of interventions on key outcomes such as income, consumption, food security, and resilience against economic shocks.
Intervention
This impact evaluation consists of two experimental studies. Experiment 1 will assess the comparative impacts of enhanced livelihoods and graduation packages, while Experiment 2 will assess the impact of a business-oriented graduation package for youth called Youth Skills Challenge (YSC).
Experiment 1 will answer the following questions:
1. What is the impact of livelihood packages on household resilience, in terms of food security, consumption, assets/savings, and income diversification?
a. What is the impact of graduation (coaching/household assets & trainings)?
b. What is the impact of the enhanced package (bundled group skills training)?
c. What is the impact of pooling graduation with the enhanced package, and what is the optimum bundle?
2. What is the cost-effectiveness of enhanced and graduation packages?
The enhanced package includes joint skills training, trainings on cooperative development and management, agricultural inputs for selected crops, and linkages for value chain development.
The graduation package includes asset transfers, coaching and mentoring, and asset-based skills training.
Experiment 2 will answer the following questions:
1. What is the impact of the Youth Skills Challenge on youth skills, IGA and earnings, employment and entrepreneurship, and empowerment?
2. What is the cost-effectiveness of the YSC program?
The YSC support includes vocational training, training and supervision for business plan development, financial linkages, and a start-up asset package.
Experimental design
The study is composed of two randomized experiments with different designs. Randomization into treatment and control will be done by the research team, in coordination with the implementer, and it will occur after the completion of the baseline survey.
Experiment 1:
We randomize at the village level, which contains one or more Savings and Loan Group (SLG) cluster. Each cluster typitcally comprises two SLGs. Villages in our two evaluation districts of Malawi, Dedza and Nkhatabay, will be randomized into one of three treatment groups and one control group. Households and individuals in treatment villages will be eligible for all intervention activities, depending on the specific intervention and their eligibility to receive the specific intervention. Households and individuals in control clusters will receive only basic services from the implementing partner while the evaluation is ongoing, which are a uniform entry point intervention for all beneficiaries. Once the evaluation is complete, clusters in the control group will receive the program as well pending their eligibility assessment and program targets. To be more specific, there will be four treatment arms (T1, T2, T3 and T4) for this experiment as follows:
• T1: those accessing only the basic.
• T2: those accessing only the enhanced package (bundled group skills training).
• T3: those accessing only graduation packages (coaching, household assets and training).
• T4: those accessing both the enhanced and graduation package.
The targeted number of study households is 6,000, though only 3,300 will be interviewed at baseline due to time constraints.
Experiment 2:
This experiment measures the impact of the Youth Skills Challenge (YSC) program, which provides training and assets to help youths establish livelihoods. Within the two experiment 1 districts (Nkhatabay and Dedza) and three other districts (Lilongwe, Rumphi and Nkhotakota), interested youth who are a member of SLGs receiving the enhanced package can apply for YSC. These applications will be scored, and the study sample will comprise twice the number of slots. We will randomize youth at the individual level into a treatment group that receives support, and a control group that does not.
The aim is to enhance youth skills, entrepreneurship skills, empowerment, employment, and earnings, for the treated. A total of 328 slots are available, hereby the experiment will include 700 youth, of which a maximum of 328 (out of 350 assigned to the treatment group) receive the program while a maximum of 350 (out of 350 assigned to the control group) do not.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.