Production- and Consumption-Oriented Interventions to Accelerate Crop Varietal Turnover in Nigeria

How to cite

Ragasa, Catherine. 2023. "Production- and Consumption-Oriented Interventions to Accelerate Crop Varietal Turnover in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012241. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12241-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Catherine Ragasa*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012241
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12241-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-01-09 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12241

Abstract

Agricultural productivity in Sub-Saharan Africa remains low despite the huge potential economic and food security importance of agriculture. In Nigeria, two important staple crops are maize and cowpea, but they persistently have low productivity: maize yield is at 1.62 ton per hectare compared to 4.2 ton per hectare in Ethiopia and about 5-6 ton per hectare on average in Southern Africa and globally. Based on LSMS 2018, only 11% of maize farming grew improved maize varieties and 7% used certified seeds. Only 3% of cowpea farmers grew improved cowpea varieties and only 2% used certified seeds. An experimental study via a randomized controlled trial is underway to verify these adoption rates, understand why adoption is very low, and test interventions to help increase adoption and improve farmers’ productivity and incomes.

The interventions focus on maize and cowpea producers (who are also maize and cowpea consumers). The interventions are targeted to address production-side constraints (through seed trial minipacks and training on good agriculture practices) and consumption-side constraints (through grain/flour minipacks and village-level cooking/tasting demonstrations).

The study setting is northern Nigeria, specifically Kaduna and Bauchi states.

Intervention

This study will evaluate the impact of production- and consumption-related interventions to address informational and behavior constraints of farmers and consumers in adopting new varieties of maize and cowpea.

The interventions involve (1) provision of seed trial packs (each 6-kg minikit consists of 1.5 kg each of white maize, orange maize, white cowpea, and brown cowpea) and (2) a consumption-side intervention that provides grain/flour mini-packs and village-level cooking/tasting demonstrations.

The varieties to be promoted are (1) newly bred varieties, with commercial seeds available in the market but not widely known and adopted by the farmers; and (2) varieties with good potential for widespread adoption based on published traits of these varieties and recommendations from breeders and feedback from seed companies. This experiment will promote the following varieties:
• SAMPEA19 (white cowpea): early medium maturity (70–75 days); medium seed size; tolerant to striga, drought, and Alectra; potential yield of 2.7 t/ha; erect; good for Sudan and Northern Guinea savannas
• FUAMPEA3 (brown cowpea): high-yielding with a potential yield of 2.4 t/ha; large seed size; medium maturity (80–85 days); semi-indeterminate; good for intercropping; suitable for Northern and Southern Guinea savannas
• SAMMAZ51 (white maize): resilient to multiple stresses; tolerant to drought and Striga hermonthica; high grain yield (8.5 t/ha); suitable for processing and consumption in the form of thick porridge and other food products
• SAMMAZ52 (orange-fleshed maize): high yielding with a potential yield of 6 t/ha; medium maturity period (100–120 days); biofortified for extra nutrition benefits, with intermediate levels of provitamin A content (9.8µg/g); mostly suitable for green maize and processing into diverse foods including child-weaning foods; suitable in Northern Guinea and Sudan Savannas.

The baseline survey shows that farmers in the study sites overwhelmingly grow and prefer white cowpea and white maize. The qualitative interviews and FGD discussions reveal, however, that some dishes are prepared with brown cowpea or orange maize.

Experimental design

The study will employ a cluster randomized controlled trial, with villages randomly assigned to different treatment arms:
• Treatment 1: Villages randomly assigned to receive seed trial pack (before Year 1 rainy season planting)
• Treatment 2: Villages randomly assigned to receive consumption-oriented intervention (grain/flour trial pack and cooking/tasting demonstration and facilitation in which the primary woman and man decision-makers within the household are invited (after harvest in Year 1)
• Treatment 3: Villages randomly assigned to receive seed trial pack (before Year 1 rainy season planting) + consumption-oriented intervention (grain/flour trial pack and cooking/tasting demonstration and facilitation in which the primary woman and man decision-makers within the household are invited) (after harvest in Year 1)
• Treatment 4: Villages randomly assigned to receive seed trial pack + training on good agricultural practices (before Year 1 rainy season planting) + consumption-oriented intervention (grain/flour trial pack and cooking/tasting demonstration and facilitation in which the primary woman and man decision-makers within the household are invited) (after harvest in Year 1)
• Control: No intervention

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
cluster=village
Clusters
252 clusters
Observations
2016 households
Arms
T1: 344 households (seed trial pack treatment) T2: 344 households (consumption pack treatment) T3: 344 households (seed trial pack + consumption treatment) C: 344 households (pure control group) T4: 320 households (seed trial pack + consumption + agriculture training) S: 320 households (non-treated in treatment T4 villages to study spillover)
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is adoption of improved varieties promoted, with “adoption” defined as farmers planting the variety in the cropping season (binary variable)
Secondary outcomes
The ITT effects (of secondary outcome indicators): • Land cultivated with the varieties promoted (in hectares) [f02a, f02b, f02b_oth, f03a + variety planted above] • Planned cultivation of varieties promoted in the next season (in hectares) • Share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties promoted (percent) • Planned share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties promoted (percent) • Land cultivated with any improved variety (in hectares) • Planned land cultivation with any improved variety in the next season (in hectares) • Share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with improved varieties (percent) • Planned share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties (percent) • Yield: value of production (naira per hectare) is used due to commonly practiced intercropping in the study area [maize_harvest_type, mz_G8_01a, mz_G8_01_units, mz_price_on_farm, mz_price_on_farm_unit, mz_price_off_farm, mz_price_off_farm_unit, cw_G8_01a, cw_G8_01_units, cw_price_on_farm_unit, cw_price_off_farm, cw_price_off_farm_unit] The spillover of non-treated (SNT) involves the same indicators as the ITT effect, except that the sample is the within-cluster nontreated households, compared to the control group: • Adoption of any variety promoted (0/1 if the household planted the variety promoted) • Planned adoption of any variety promoted in next season (0/1) • Land cultivated with the varieties promoted (in hectares) • Planned cultivation of varieties promoted in the next season (in hectares) • Share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties promoted (percent) • Planned share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties promoted (percent) • Land cultivated with any improved variety (in hectares) • Planned land cultivation with any improved variety in the next season (in hectares) • Share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with improved varieties (percent) • Planned share of land area with maize and cowpea planted with varieties (percent) • Yield of maize and cowpea: value of production (naira per hectare) is used because of commonly practiced intercropping in the study area Other outcomes to explore: • Income from maize and cowpea sales [mz_G8_01k, cw_G8_01k + yield and price data above] • Gender parity indicators (composite index, and several subindexes, following the Abbreviated Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture Index, A-WEAI—see Malapit et al. 2017) [7 modules on A-WEAI] Other indicators to collect related to the valuation and experience of farmers on the varieties promoted, in comparison to current varieties: • Production cost • Other (desirable and undesirable) production traits • Processing, milling, and cooking qualities • Desirable and undesirable qualities of the maize and cowpea in terms of color, size, taste, texture, appearance, and others • Desirable and undesirable qualities of the maize and cowpea when cooked (in different dishes)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords