The Adoption and Impact of Air Purifiers: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Mexico City

How to cite

Gazze, Ludovica; Hoffmann, Bridget; Behrer, Patrick. 2023. "The Adoption and Impact of Air Purifiers: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Mexico City." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012227. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12227-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ludovica Gazze* , Bridget Hoffmann , Patrick Behrer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012227
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12227-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-16 – 2027-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12227

Abstract

According to the World Health Organization, air pollution—both ambient and residential-- is the top environmental risk to health. Accordingly, air pollution is a growing topic of study. However, the bulk of the literature is focused on two disparate issues, outdoor air quality in cities and residential air quality related to cookstoves in rural areas. In contrast, very few studies focus on residential air quality in cities of the developing world. Yet, indoor air quality, and especially residential air quality, is likely to be critical for individuals’ outcomes, as people spend 60% of their time indoors. For example, residential air quality could affect sleep duration and quality, which in turn could affect health, wellbeing, and performance. Because outdoor air pollution levels are often higher in poor neighborhoods than in rich neighborhoods and pollutants, such as particulate matter, better permeate older and poorly constructed dwellings, residential air quality may exacerbate health and economic inequalities. Documenting the extent, determinants, and effects of air quality in urban homes in Mexico City will provide an understanding of the scale of the problem. Evidence on the barriers to improving residential air quality and the policy interventions that can overcome them is key to mitigating the impacts of pollution and addressing poverty for millions of households in fast-developing and highly polluted cities of countries like Mexico, India, and China.
This project addresses the following research questions:
1. What is the level of air pollution in a home in a below median income neighborhood in highly polluted city of a middle-income country?
2. What barriers prevent adoption of mitigating technology (air purifiers) among households in a below median income neighborhood in this context and what policies can overcome them?
3. What are the health and wellbeing effects of improved residential air quality for households in a below median income neighborhood in this context?

Experimental design

Households will be randomized into one of the following three mutually exclusive intervention groups prior to baseline:
• 10-day Trial (200 households): Households will receive an offer for a free 10-day purifier trial (T-10).
• 90-day Trial (200 households): Households will receive an offer for a 90-day purifier trial (T-90).
• Control (C) (200 households): Households will not receive the purifier.

In addition, at endline, we will cross-randomize households into one of three information treatments:
• General Info (200 households): Households will receive information on how purifiers improved air quality and sleep during our pilot in Mexico City.
• Personalized Info (200 households): Households will receive information on how purifiers improved air quality and sleep among households with similar observable characteristics to theirs during our pilot.
• Control (C) (200 households): Households will not receive additional information.

Design details

Randomization method
Prior to the baseline survey, we will randomize the order of enrolled households into the three intervention treatment groups, generating a list for each enumerator (e.g., a sequence of T10, C, C, T90, T90, T10, ....) that enumerators will follow as they recruit households. In addition, prior to endline, we will cross-randomize households into one of three information treatments.
Randomization unit
Household.
Clusters
600 households for full study.
Observations
600 households for full study.
Arms
Control: 200 HHs (roughly 1/3 no info, 1/3 general info, 1/3 personalized) T10: 200 HHs (roughly 1/3 no info, 1/3 general info, 1/3 personalized) T90: 200 HHS (roughly 1/3 no info, 1/3 general info, 1/3 personalized)
Primary outcomes
- Air quality: Hourly PM 2.5 at the household level. - Sleep quality: Standardized index at the participant-day level. - Wellbeing: Standardized index at the participant level as measured at endline. - Willingness-to-pay: Incentivized stated price at the participant level as measured at endline.
Secondary outcomes
- Attrition: share of days with usable wearable data and endline responses for primary outcomes - Physical health, as measured by index pf self-reports and metrics provided by the wearables (resting heart rate, daily heart rate variability in healthy range) - Health behaviors: number of steps and time spent in sedentary activities (wearables) - Self-reported sleep quality index - Self-reported index of awareness of air quality issues and measures to reduce exposure - Behavior: ventilation, smoking, and cooking habits as measured by self-reports as well as CO2 - Purifier usage

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords