Robo‑Advising: How Investors Respond to Preference‑Based vs. Debiasing Recommendations

How to cite

Li, Qin; Meng, Juanjuan; Jiang, Jiajun; Liu, Yu-Jane. 2023. "Robo‑Advising: How Investors Respond to Preference‑Based vs. Debiasing Recommendations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012219. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12219-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Qin Li* , Juanjuan Meng , Jiajun Jiang , Yu-Jane Liu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012219
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12219-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-08-01 – 2026-08-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12219

Abstract

The household finance literature has found that investors often deviate from optimal investment behavior and suffer wealth losses due to factors such as incomplete information, lack of financial knowledge, and behavioral biases. Investment advisors perform multiple functions including information provision, investor education, and asset allocation recommendations, serving as crucial means to assist investors. Currently, there are two popular logics for investment advisor’s asset allocation recommendations: catering to investor preferences and educating investor. Exploring which asset allocation logic and design are more comprehensive, trustworthy, and beneficial to investors’ welfare holds significant implications for the upgrade of advisory services, development of financial markets, and enhancement of social welfare.

The experiment will randomly divide users of a certain bank’s APP into four groups: control group, preference catering group, loss aversion education group, and mental accounting education group. All users will first report their current asset allocation and complete a series of questionnaires on basic information and behavioral preferences. The control group will not receive any recommendation. The preference catering group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal based on the investor’s behavioral parameters. The loss aversion education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the loss aversion parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. The mental accounting education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the mental accounting parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. Finally, all users will report the asset allocation they consider to be most appropriate.

Intervention

The experiment will randomly divide users of a certain bank’s APP into four groups: control group, preference catering group, loss aversion education group, and mental accounting education group.
All users will first report their current asset allocation and complete a series of questionnaires on basic information and behavioral preferences. The control group will not receive any recommendation. The preference catering group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal based on the investor’s behavioral parameters. The loss aversion education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the loss aversion parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. The mental accounting education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the mental accounting parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. Finally, all users will report the asset allocation they consider to be most appropriate.

Experimental design

The experiment will randomly divide users of a certain bank’s APP into four groups: control group, preference catering group, loss aversion education group, and mental accounting education group.
All users will first report their current asset allocation and complete a series of questionnaires on basic information and behavioral preferences. The control group will not receive any recommendation. The preference catering group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal based on the investor’s behavioral parameters. The loss aversion education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the loss aversion parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. The mental accounting education group will be recommended an asset allocation that is algorithmically calculated to be optimal but with the modification of the mental accounting parameter to be fully rational while keeping the investor’s other behavioral parameters unchanged. Finally, all users will report the asset allocation they consider to be most appropriate.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
About 200,000 individuals exposed to the experiment (about 8,000 actually entering the experiment)
Observations
About 200,000 individuals exposed to the experiment (about 8,000 actually entering the experiment)
Arms
50,000 individuals exposed (about 2,000 actually entering the experiment) in control group; 50,000 individuals exposed (about 2,000 actually entering the experiment) in preference catering group; 50,000 individuals exposed (about 2,000 actually entering the experiment) in loss aversion education group; 50,000 individuals exposed (about 2,000 actually entering the experiment) in mental accounting education group
Primary outcomes
Asset allocation decision
Secondary outcomes
Browsing behavior

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords