Job rotation and worker performance

How to cite

Hoffman, Mitchell; Chotiputsilp, Ratchanon; Kim, Taeho; Wang, Shing-Yi. 2023. "Job rotation and worker performance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012136. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12136-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mitchell Hoffman* , Ratchanon Chotiputsilp , Taeho Kim , Shing-Yi Wang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012136
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12136-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-08-01 – 2025-02-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
M50, O14
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12136

Abstract

How should firms allocate workers to jobs? A standard approach is for firms to assign workers to jobs and to train workers for one job. An alternative approach, called cross-training or cross-skilling, is for firms to rotate workers to different jobs while providing training for multiple jobs. Job rotation and cross-skilling may have several benefits. First, it may allow workers to better take advantage of comparative advantage, thus increasing productivity. Second, it may make workers happier, both because they get to choose a job which they enjoy more and because they appreciate the firm developing multiple capabilities. Third, cross-skilling may increase organizational agility and flexibility, as well as broad knowledge, allowing employees to better understand the needs of the full organization, and being able to step into different roles. Cross-skilling seems to be successfully used in several leading firms, such as the Spanish grocery chain Mercadona, but we have little rigorous evidence on the impact of cross-skilling.

We collaborate with a leading garment manufacturer in Southeast Asia to examine the impacts of job rotation. The experiment will involve all new workers and recently hired existing workers. In the control group, workers receive the standard approach of assignment and training for one job. In the treatment group, workers receive training for multiple jobs at the firm. After training, workers and managers state preferences regarding the assignment of workers to jobs, and workers are assigned to jobs using a version of the deferred acceptance algorithm. We examine how the treatment affects performance, employee turnover, work satisfaction, and employee skill.

Intervention

Treatment workers will be randomly selected to join the company's rotation program. At the end of all the rotation cycles (2 other jobs for a week each), the firm and the pilot workers will work together to decide which job function fits the workers best in a way that takes into account both the preferences of the workers and the evaluations by managers (in a deferred acceptance algorithm used in two-sided matching). The control workers will continue to work in a job that was initially assigned by the firm.

Experimental design

New workers and recently hired existing workers at the firm will be randomly assigned to control or treatment. Control is the standard approach of assignment and training for one job for new workers. For existing workers, the control condition means continuing with their current work.

Under the treatment, workers will go through a job rotation where they will try multiple jobs. Jobs can include sewing, heat transfer, embroidery, cutting, quality control, ironing/packing, warehouse/logistic, and material/stock. Which jobs are available will vary by factory and over time depending on work needs of the company. However, treatment workers will experience at least two jobs.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will occur in the office via a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization occurs at the individual worker level.
Clusters
New hires will be batched by the factory-month that they started and individual-level randomization will happen at the batch level. We expect to obtain a sample of 500-1,000 employees.
Observations
New hires will be batched by the factory-month that they started and individual-level randomization will happen at the batch level. We expect to obtain a sample of 500-1,000 employees.
Arms
We expect to obtain a sample of 500-1,000 employees.
Primary outcomes
The first main outcome will be worker performance. This will be measured using the endline survey. It will also be measured using administrative data from the firm. The second main outcome will be employee turnover. This will be measured using administrative data. The third main outcome will be employee satisfaction. This will be measured using questions on the endline survey. It will include satisfaction with one's particular job, as well as general satisfaction at the firm. The fourth main outcome will be an employee's skill at their job. We aim to measure whether workers are more likely to find a job that they are good at in the treatment group. This will be measured using a skills assessment. Finally, we will measure whether workers change their preferences over various jobs after rotation.
Secondary outcomes
Probability of a worker being temporarily moved to a different task/team, violations and injury (data permitting)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords