Nation-states rely on a sense of shared identity constructed through narrative. Anderson (1983) argued that nations are “Imagined Communities” constructed by narrative, schools, museums, monuments and maps. We study the impact of a high-school program in Mexico that takes low-income students to visit sites that are an integral part of the Mexican nation’s history. We examine whether this generates a heightened sense of national identity and reduces feelings of exclusion, and the extent to which this generates public good provision, political participation, and government legitimacy. We do this as part of a new program created by the government of Puebla (“Journeys of National Heritage”) that is currently being scaled up.
Intervention
We work with “Journeys of National Heritage”, a program run by the city of Puebla, Mexico, in which high school students from low-income schools with a high proportion of Indigenous students are taken on a 5-hour tour of the most important historical cultural sites of Puebla, spanning indigenous settlement, the war for Independence, the subsequent revolution against the dictatorship, and UNESCO cultural heritage sites. The tour culminates by exploring the underground tunnels and emerging onto the battlefield of the famous Cinco de Mayo victory over the French. The Tour script was developed in collaboration with local experts from textbooks, national curricula, and sites of Puebla to generate a vivid and lyrical narrative of the mestizo national identity of Mexico, emphasizing national pride and ethnic inclusion. History is described as a continuing line from the original indigenous Mexicans to today, with Mexicans of all classes and skin colors present in art, traditions, and battles. The script emphasizes the critical role that women have played in Mexico’s history. Each tour consisted of 20-25 students with professional tour guides trained in the script and an enumerator for observation throughout. The intervention started Sept 2023, and we uploaded it on that date but submitted it in June 2024, before the medium-run follow-up survey but after the short-run survey.
Experimental design
Randomization will be done at the student level (stratified within classroom and student characteristics) within about 25 public high schools with low-income second-year students (16-17 years of age). We will randomize close to 2600 students within-school and within-classroom students to the following arms:
●Treatment (1300 students): tour of historical places. This will consist of a 5-hour tour of the major historical sites in Puebla that connect through time and have nationwide significance. ●Control (1300 students): will not go on the tour but will have a normal school day instead.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization is done in the office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The individual students
Clusters
No cluster. Individual student randomziation
Observations
2600 approximately
Arms
1300 students on each of the two arms.
Primary outcomes
1a) Increase in self-reported nationalism and national identity. Survey measures include the following: War = 1 if answered affirmatively to the question “If Mexico were in a war and needed volunteers, and they asked you to enlist, Would you do it?” None like Mex =1 if answered "None" to the following question: “Thinking about the countries on this list, which country would you like Mexico to resemble more?”. Mex Identity=1 if they answer "traditions and culture", or "nationality", in the following question: “Which of the following defines your identity more”, Religion, friends, sports/music, economic class, politics, traditions and culture, nationality." Plans to stay in Mex =1 answered "Not abroad" to the question "Where would you like to carry out your plans after High School?", and other measures of nationalism (including applying for Mexican military ID). We would also create a standardized index of these measures.
1b) Increased revealed measures of nationalism and national identity: Higher number of times they choose Mexican art (incentivized questions measuring if they want to have Mexican vs. European art in posters). Higher enrollment to the parade where Parade=1 if they enrolled in marching or helping in Mexican national holiday parades. Higher rate for starting the application to get the military ID card, among others. Higher pride in Mexico using IAT. We will also create a standardized index for these.
2a) Self-perception: more willing to say they have Indigenous origins (Indigenous =1 if answered yes to "Do you consider yourself to be of Indigenous ancestry?" Higher self-reporting they have darker skin color. Higher willingness to devote their incentive money to buy a DNA test to inquire about the ancestry. We will also use a standardized index for these. Moreover, we expect lower measured negative self-feelings in an essay analyzed with the NRC Emotion Lexicon (anger, sadness, fear, and negative emotions).
2b) Perceptions of other Mexicans and inclusion. Higher likelihood to be willing to interact with darker-skinned people (if they are themselves dark). More willing to describe dark-skinned people with positive characteristics. Second-order beliefs: reporting it is more likely that others see them as Mexican, Indigenous, or darker skinned.
3) No backlash towards foreigners: we expect no negative effect measured by incentivized dictator games, no differential affect measured with affective thermometer questions ("We would like to know your stance towards some groups. For the following groups, rate them from 0 to 10 (0 means that you completely reject”. Americans; Europeans). No self-reported difference in trust. Foreigners =1 if the student trusts foreigners (3 or 4, in a 1-4 Likert). No difference in whether Mexicans should have priority in jobs (dummy =1 of Strongly Agree, Agree; =0 if Disagree, Strongly Disagree to the question "when jobs are scarce in Mexico, employers should give priority to Mexicans over foreigners"). Not rating pictures of lighter skinned people with negative attributes. We will also create a standardized index of these.
4a) Self-reporting higher involvement in community and community self-efficacy. Higher rates of affirmative answers in Can make a difference =1 if the answer agrees or strongly agrees with the question "Young people in Mexico can improve the country by voting and participating in political life", and also in Responsible for my community =1 if answers Yes to "I feel responsible for my community." We will also create a standardized index of these.
4b) Revealed more actual participation in the community. More willing to enroll in blood donations database. More willing to enroll to clean public spaces, as in Volunteering club =1 if the student enrolled in club to clean streets and parks and school. We will also create a standardized index of these.
5a) Increased government legitimacy and civic participation (self-reported): Higher voting intentions, "Plan to vote" =1 if student plans to vote when she turns 18. Higher satisfaction with democracy=1 if student is satisfied with democracy in Mexico. Higher interest in politics asked directly. More informed about factual current events. Job in Gov =1 if answered Look for a job in government to the question "What are your plans after finishing high school?". We will also create a standardized index of these.
5b) Increased government legitimacy and civic participation (revealed). More willingness to be a poll worker, Poll Worker =1 if the student is willing to register as poll worker for the next election. Higher willingness to devote incentive money for a subscription to newspaper. We will also create a standardized index of these.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.