The Effect of Formal-relational Contract Management Training in the Public Sector
How to cite
Petersen, Ole Helby; Brogaard, Lena; Potoski, Matthew.
2023. "The Effect of Formal-relational Contract Management Training in the Public Sector." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012059.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12059-1.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
Ole Helby Petersen*
, Lena Brogaard
, Matthew Potoski
This trial examines the effect of formal-relational contract management training in a national- scale randomized field experiment in Denmark. Participants are local and regional public contract managers receiving a 5 ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) masterclass training in formal-relational contract management.
Intervention
The study is based on a focused 5 ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) master level class in formal-relational contract management as a free course offered to all local and regional government contract managers (purchasing officers, contract managers, heads of contracting offices, and similar job categories) in Denmark. The trial is a delayed- start treatment design with two interventions. Contract managers assigned to the treatment group receive the training in the first wave (September to November 2023), and those the control group receives the training in the second wave (September to November 2024).
Experimental design
The participants consist of all local and regional government public contract managers in Denmark who volunteered for the contract management training. The participants are stratified by organization type and size, and randomly assigned to the treatment group or the control group, with the treatment group receiving treatment in Fall 2023 and the control group receiving a delayed-start treatment in the Fall of 2024. The contract management training consists of a focused 5 ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) course in formal-relational contracting in the public sector, developed by the research team for this trial.
Design details
Randomization method
In office by a computer
Randomization unit
This is a cluster randomized trial. Public contract managers are clustered at their organizations (municipalities, regions, local public utility companies, local public transport companies).
Clusters
82 local and regional purchasing agencies
Observations
208 public contract managers
Arms
App. 41 purchasing agencies receive contract management training in the first wave (September to November 2023). App. 41 purchasing agencies (control group) receive contract management training in the second wave (September to November 2024).
Primary outcomes
The trial focuses on three groups of outcomes:
1) Program Learning. Did the program increased participants’ ability to and confidence (self-efficacy) in using a FRC approach to prepare and manage contracts?
1a: Public contract managers' ability to use FRC when preparing and managing contracts.
1b: Public contract managers' self-efficacy in using FRC when preparing and managing contracts.
2) Contract Management Practice. Did the program increase participants’ use of FRC writing and enforcement practices?
2a: Public contract managers' use FRC shared goals and guiding principles.
2b: Public contract managers' use of four FRC governance mechanisms: 1) penalties and rewards, 2) communication and information sharing, 3) dispute resolution, 4) procedures for contract amendments.
2c: Public contract managers’ use of FRC enforcement to manage the buyer-seller relation during the contract period –the four FRC governance mechanisms mentioned in 2b.
3) Contract Performance. Did the program improve the outcomes of contracts for the buyers and sellers?
3a: Buyers' and sellers' perception of value from the purchase (price, product quality, relationship satisfaction).
3b: Buyers’ and sellers’ perceptions of whether the other party was behaving in a “cooperative” spirit in line with FRC objectives.
3c: Buyer’s perception of transaction costs (time, effort and other resources spent to make the transaction happen).
We will correct for multiple testing within each of these three groups of outcomes.
Secondary outcomes
After completion of the treatment, we will perform exploratory analyses of additional connections between the treatment and possible outcomes within different subgroups such as simple versus complex products and between different types of contract managers (experience, education, gender) and characteristics of buying agencies. The aim of the secondary outcomes is to identify potential areas for additional research.
To explore whether the effects of treatment differ across different products, we will conduct secondary analyses of outcomes 1, 2 and 3 at varying levels of product complexity. In addition, we will conduct exploratory analyses using additional data culled from the RPA contracts.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.