Comparing Different Approaches to Entrepreneurial Learning: A Field Experiment in Pakistan

How to cite

Apostoloski, Nenad; Spina, Chiara. 2023. "Comparing Different Approaches to Entrepreneurial Learning: A Field Experiment in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012047. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12047-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nenad Apostoloski* , Chiara Spina

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012047
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12047-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-19 – 2024-11-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
M13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12047

Abstract

Failure is widely acknowledged as a critical component of the organizational learning and innovation processs. Learning from failure, in particular, seems extremely relevant in the context of entrepreneurship, where failure often emerges as the predominant outcome. Remarkably, most entrepreneurship training programs predominantly emphasize success stories of entrepreneurs, without leveraging the learning potential that come from stories of failure. Consequently, we investigate how entrepreneurs assimilate lessons from the failure of others differently compared to the success of others and, subsequently, how these distinct learning approaches impact the decisions entrepreneurs make about their businesses.

To investigate this research question, we conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT) aimed at providing robust empirical evidence and assessing the effects of adopting a "learning from failure" approach vis-à-vis the conventional "learning from success" approach.
In this study, about 300 entrepreneurs participate to a training program focused on market validation with the same structure: we utilize robust frameworks and tools commonly employed in entrepreneurial education, we provide practical examples from other founders, we facilitate discussions on essential thematic elements, and provide opportunities for participants to reflect on the content. However, frameworks, examples, discussions, and self-reflections focus on learning from the failure of others for one group (half of the participants), and on learning from the success of others for the other group (half of the participants). Our expectation is that both types of training will benefit entrepreneurs but in different ways. We will measure outcomes related to both entrepreneurial intentions, actions, and decision-making processes to gain deeper insights into how distinct learning methodologies influence the development of new businesses.

Intervention

Participants will receive 7 sessions of in-person training. These sessions will include interactive lectures and coaching by qualified mentors/instructors each working with a subset of the sample to ensure small interactive sessions. Treated and control startups will receive the same amount of training on market validation (on topics like business model canvas, customers' interviews, minimum viable products/services, etc.). One group will be taught using key themes, insights, robust frameworks and examples of entrepreneurial success. Another group of treated startups will be taught using key themes, insights, robust frameworks and examples of entrepreneurial failure.

Experimental design

The RCT focuses on early-stage entrepreneurs without restrictions in terms of industries. We advertise the program through digital channels as a general course overseeing all the important aspects of market validation. The course is free of charge in order to ensure the participation of those with limited financial resources. Entrepreneurs receive training in-person. The same amount of training is offered to the two groups in order to ensure comparability. Multiple instructors/coaches will be trained to deliver the training using standard materials, purposely designed. Each instructor/coach teaches two classes (one subgroup of startups treated with the learning from failure approach, and one subgroup of startups treated with the learning from success approach). The research team designs, coordinates and oversees all the activities, ensuring that the learning modules and coaching activities are appropriately carried out by the instructors/coaches.

Design details

Randomization method
Pure parallel randomization, done by a computer using STATA. After being randomly assigned into one of the two groups (control or treatment), multiple subgroups of startups (of about 25 startups) will be created and randomly matched with the instructors/coaches so that each instructor/coach teaches two subgroups - of approximately 25 startups. Randomization checks: mean values comparison and t-tests across groups.
Randomization unit
Start-ups
Clusters
Not clustered
Observations
300 businesses X 12 observations = 3600 observations
Arms
300 startups (150 in the treatment group, 150 in the control group)
Primary outcomes
We are interested in the performance of the new businesses as a primary outcome. Having in mind the complexity of measuring the performance of new businesses we are basing our outcomes on key steps of the entrepreneurial development process. This includes intentions (i.e., intention to close business, to pivot, to make revenue, etc.) as an important precursor to action and the actual actions taken (closing the business, pivoting, making revenue) of the entrepreneurs.
Secondary outcomes
We are also interested in understanding whether the exposure to different training affects other outcomes related to psychological constructs: - Entrepreneurial Persistence, - Entrepreneurial Self-Efficacy, and - Entrepreneurial Passion - Optimism

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords