Competitive environments are known to drive more efficient outputs, and organizations frequently use contests to boost effort and performance levels. However, it remains unclear how increasing competitive pressure impacts individuals' self-assessment of their abilities and their use of resources. This raises the question of whether individuals and organizations might resort to unethical behavior to gain a competitive advantage. In this project, we will conduct an online experiment where participants will compete against peers in various competitive settings to explore this issue.
Intervention
Each participant is randomly assigned to a specific treatment to complete individual real effort tasks. They consistently engage in the same real effort production activities.
Experimental design
Participants are asked to complete a real effort task. The experiment is conducted on an online platform that guides all participants through the process, which is self-administered. After receiving instructions and completing an unpaid practice exercise, the paid portion of the experiment begins. Participants complete two sets of five rounds each. The first set of five rounds is identical across all treatments, while a treatment variation is introduced in the second set. Participants are paid based on the sum of two randomly chosen rounds—one from the first set and one from the second set. The experiment concludes with a survey.
Design details
Randomization method
The initial session will be assigned randomly according to the standard protocol implemented by the lab (via computer). We aim for a balanced sample, so final sessions may be scheduled on an as-needed basis. Participants will not know which treatment they are assigned to when they sign up for the study.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
0
Observations
240 participants
Arms
60/80 participants per treatment
Primary outcomes
We are interested in individual productivity based on the competitive environment and the individual incentive scheme to which participants are assigned. One primary outcome metric will be the variation in individual contributions (investing efforts vs using the autosolve button) when a participant is placed in a specific competitive environment, which varies across sessions. We will also consider the amount of time spent on the second screen. Each participant takes part in only one session. We will analyse these differences using t-tests and standard panel regression analysis and difference in differences techniques.
Secondary outcomes
The pay rate (low or high) of a participant depends on the outcome of a Tullock contest against two randomly chosen opponents. This setup allows us to predict the amount of effort exerted in the tournament and assess a participant's ethical engagement. We also measure participants' beliefs using a survey question at the end of the experiment. Additionally, we evaluate participants' ethical perceptions regarding the use of the autosolve button and the negative externalities triggered by its use. Participants are also asked a set of questions about their personality. Finally, we capture beliefs about one's relative ability and the extent to which participants believe others in the experiment resorted to using the autosolve button to complete their tasks.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.