A Dictator Game Experiment with Face Mask Wearers and Non-mask Wearers in Japan

How to cite

Sasaki, Shusaku; Kurokawa, Hirofumi; Nakata, Taisuke. 2023. "A Dictator Game Experiment with Face Mask Wearers and Non-mask Wearers in Japan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012025. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12025-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shusaku Sasaki* , Hirofumi Kurokawa , Taisuke Nakata

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012025
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12025-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2026-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12025

Abstract

In this study, we conduct a dictator game experiment with face mask wearers and non-mask wearers in Japan, and ascertain allocation tendencies between two anonymous individuals, between two mask wearers or two non-mask wearers, and between a mask wearer and a non-mask wearer. By so doing, we assess “ingroup-favoritism,” “ingroup bias,” and “outgroup bias” of the mask wearers and non-mask wearers, respectively. Here, ingroup-favoritism is defined as the difference between the money amounts allocated in the dictator game experiment to an individual of the same group (i.e., a recipient who wears a mask for the mask wearers and a recipient who does not wear a mask for the non-mask wearers) and to an individual of the different group (i.e., a recipient who does not wear a mask for the mask wearers and a recipient who wears a mask for the non-mask wearers). Also, ingroup bias is defined as the difference between the money amounts allocated to an individual of the same group as the allocator and to an anonymous individual, while outgroup bias is defined as the difference between the money amounts allocated to an individual of a different group from the allocator’s and to an anonymous one. We also examine whether the biases depend on the recipient’s nationality or not.

Intervention

We set the following seven treatment conditions in the dictator game experiment:

A) Anonymous: A recipient is anonymous for an allocator.
B) Japanese mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is Japanese.
C) Japanese non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is Japanese.
D) East Asian mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and East Asian.
E) East Asian non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and East Asian.
F) Non-East Asian mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and non-East Asian.
G) Non-East Asian non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and non-East Asian.

Experimental design

We conduct dictator game experiments in the following seven conditions:

A) Anonymous: A recipient is anonymous for an allocator.
B) Japanese mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is Japanese.
C) Japanese non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is Japanese.
D) East Asian mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and East Asian.
E) East Asian non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and East Asian.
F) Non-East Asian mask wearers: A recipient wears a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and non-East Asian.
G) Non-East Asian non-mask wearers: A recipient does not wear a mask. The recipient nationality is non-Japanese and non-East Asian.

Each participant in the five dictator game experiments as an allocator. We randomly set the order of the above conditions to create seven groups in each of the mask wearers and non-mask wearers samples. The order of five dictator games as follows:

Group 1. A⇒A⇒A⇒A⇒A
Group 2. A⇒B⇒C⇒F⇒G
Group 3. A⇒C⇒B⇒E⇒D
Group 4. A⇒D⇒E⇒B⇒C
Group 5. A⇒E⇒D⇒C⇒B
Group 6. A⇒F⇒G⇒B⇒C
Group 7. A⇒G⇒F⇒C⇒B

First, we set up six groups: the Japanese condition (B and C), the East Asian condition (D and E) and the Non-East Asian condition (F and G). In all groups, the first among the five games is played in the anonymous condition (A). In the second and third games, for each nationality condition, we randomly set either the in-group condition (B, D and F) or the out-group condition (C, E and G). In Groups 2 and 3, the fourth and fifth games will be played in the East Asian or Non-East Asian condition. In Groups 4, 5, 6 and 7, the fourth and fifth games are played in the Japanese condition. The order of the in-group and out-group conditions is set to correspond to the order of the in-group and out-group conditions in the second and third games. Consequently, each of the mask wearing and non-wearing samples have six groups. Furthermore, we create Group 1 as a control group, where we present the anonymous condition (A) five times, to address potential order effects caused by successive participation in the dictator games. Totally, each of the mask wearing and non-wearing samples have seven groups, including the control group.

We conduct the between-analysis to test the existence of ingroup favoritism, ingroup bias, and outgroup bias in each of face mask wearers and non-mask wearers. We also investigate whether the mask wearers’ ingroup favoritism change between when the nationality of the recipient pair is Japanese and when the nationality of the recipient pair is non-Japanese. Our experimental design allows for both between- and within-individual comparisons. We further conduct the within-analysis to check the robustness of the between-analysis.

We explain more details in the attachment of the pre-analysis plan.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization by a survey company. The strata are based on sex, age, and region.
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
N/A
Observations
3,360 individuals (1,680 mask wearers and 1,680 non-mask wearers)
Arms
1,680 mask wearers include seven treatment groups (6*240 mask wearers = 1440 mask wearers) and one control group (240 mask wearers). Similarly, 1,680 non-mask wearers include seven treatment groups (6*240 non-mask wearers = 1440 non-mask wearers) and one control group (240 non-mask wearers).
Primary outcomes
Allocation in the dictator game experiment (More specifically, within-difference between the allocated amounts in the second dictator game and the first anonymous dictator game. Please see the details in the pre-analysis plan.)
Secondary outcomes
Attitudes toward the COVID-19-related policies (Agree or disagree for the policy of easing restrictions related to infectious disease control)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords