Improvements on valuing gains in health status with stated preferences
How to cite
ARAUJO, Daniel HERRERA; Rheinberger, Christoph; Hammitt, James.
2023. "Improvements on valuing gains in health status with stated preferences." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012020.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12020-1.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
Daniel HERRERA ARAUJO*
, Christoph Rheinberger
, James Hammitt
This project is motivated by the increasing need for economic tools enabling French authorities to rank policies that seek to reduce risks to life and limb. As of 2012, the multi-annual French public budget programming bill requires that for all publicly funded investments a full socioeconomic evaluation be carried out before implementation. Government agencies around the world, including French authorities, typically employ estimates of the value per statistical life (VSL) to quantify the benefits of regulation-induced or investment-induced changes in mortality risk. In the socioeconomic evaluation sphere, VSL is one of the most influential metrics.
A first objective of our research aims at empirically eliciting both the VSL and the WTP for improved quality-of-life in France, as well as the bounds on the WTP for improved quality-of-life. The project’s second objective is to provide empirical support for an innovative method for estimating VSL in stated preferences surveys: the use of non-marginal risk reductions.
Intervention
The project ANR-20-CE36-0010-01 (VHEALTH hereafter) aims at providing new tools to assess monetary values for improved health and longevity. Our research aims at empirically identifying the upper and lower bounds for the value of improved health and longevity along with VSL estimates in France. The project's second objective aims at providing empirical support for an innovative method for estimating the VSL through SP: the use of non-marginal risk reductions. Most papers ask respondents to value small risk reductions to elicit VSL. These have the advantage that under conventional theoretical assumptions, WTP should be nearly proportional to the proposed risk reduction for small risk reductions.
Experimental design
Reported in the PAP.
Design details
Randomization method
Reported in the PAP.
Randomization unit
Individual level.
Clusters
5150 respondents.
Observations
5150 respondents.
Arms
We plan around 170 respondents per block.
Primary outcomes
There are three primary outcomes:
The willingness to pay elicited. Within the WTP task, we ask respondents to consider a status-quo situation described by five attributes: (1) risk of developing cancer and dying from it; (2) risk of developing cancer and recovering from it; (3) quality-of-life conditional on having cancer; (4) duration of cancer spell; and (5) cost for buying regular food products. Respondents are asked to compare it with a scenario where, at a higher cost, the ‘risk of developing cancer and dying from it’ and/or the ‘risk of developing cancer and recovering from it’ are reduced via the purchase of /safety-certified food products.
The standard gamble. The standard gamble asks respondents to assume that they are diagnosed with cancer and two alternative treatments are available: a low-risk (or no risk) treatment that allows them to (nearly) avoid death from cancer, but with which their health status remains compromised for a specified duration; or a high-risk experimental treatment that is highly effective in some people but not effective in others. We assign half of the respondents to a "no-risk" vs. "high- risk" treatment, while the other half are assigned to a "low-risk" vs. "high-risk" treatment. The "low-risk" treatment randomly assigns between a risk of 1 in 1000 or 2 in 1000 of dying, even if taking the treatment.
Following the WTP question, the standard gamble and some debriefing questions, respondents receive, at random, one of three alternative sets of questions about hypothetical financial risks. The first set of questions will follow Barsky et al. (1997) elicitation for risk aversion. Following Hammitt & Haninger (2010), a second set of questions instructs respondents to
decide about two job offers. Specifically, they can choose between a salary job, which pays an annual salary that increases modestly each year, and a bonus job, which pays a smaller salary but offers with some probability a large annual bonus. Finally, we adapt a version of the Eckel and Grossman risk elicitation task (2002, 2008) which consists of asking subjects to choose their preferred gamble from among six possible choices.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are respondents self-assess health.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.