Remote work policies remain controversial mainly because of productivity concerns. The existing literature highlights how the remote setting affects individual productivity yet little is known about how the remote setting affects work in teams - where productivity losses are potentially higher given the additional role of beliefs over partner productivity. Our study closes this gap by examining the effort of individuals randomly assigned to work in either a remote or office setting with partners who are remote and office based.
Intervention
Participants are randomly assigned a location (in the lab or working remotely) and teammates. They always engage in the same real effort production tasks.
Experimental design
Participants are asked to complete a real effort typing task. The work is performed on an online platform which guides all participants through the experiment. The experiment is self-guided for both office workers and remote workers to ensure that the work platform and information given to all participants is identical. After a set of instructions and an unpaid practice work exercise, the paid portion of the experiment begins with an individual work round, followed by two team work rounds. The experiment ends with a basic survey.
Design details
Randomization method
We will use random.org for determining the initial sessions to conduct. We aim for a balanced sample and as such the final sessions may be run on an as-needed basis. Subjects do not know which treatment they are in when they sign up to take part in the study.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
0
Observations
310
Arms
165 in each team payment scheme.
Primary outcomes
We are interested in individual and team productivity based on the location of the individual and their teammates as well as the team incentive scheme. One primary outcome metric will be the difference in team contributions (output) when a participant is paired with office-based vs. remote-based teammates. We will test for differences using t-tests and standard (random effects) panel regression analysis. We will also examine overall productivity (individual output + team output) by location of the worker, using t-tests and regressional analysis to determine differences in overall productivity. Last, we will also examine the proportion shared (constructed variable explained below) using t-tests and regression analysis.
Secondary outcomes
The minimum effort pay scheme game has a prediction that the amount given to the team directly measures beliefs of partner productivity. We also measure beliefs using a survey question at the end of the experiment as a comparison to this explicit measure. The revenue-sharing game does not have a belief measurement directly taken from the game, so we only have the survey question at the end to measure. In all cases, we ask whether the remote or office worker partners contributed more to the team (a direct binary measure of productivity). In the minimum effort treatment, we also ask an incentivized belief question about the minimum amount contributed to the group account by both types of partners. We ask the same question in the revenue sharing treatment but shift from the minimum to a question about the average contribution of teammates. We use all of these questions to examine stated beliefs and to use these beliefs to explain work behavior in the team. We use these beliefs to isolate different types of subjects: those who believe office workers are more productive, those that believe remote workers are more productive and those who believe there are no differences in productivity by work location. We also measure ability in a single round at the start of the experiment, where subjects are paid a piece rate for completed tasks. This is used as an explanatory variable in regression analysis.
Earlier version of this experiment were not registered and they were run prior to Covid. A secondary outcome of interest is whether or not there is a change due to covid. Only the minimum effort treatments were conducted before Covid. Revenue sharing treatments and additional minimum effort treatments will be conducted post-pandemic.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.