Alleviating Constraints to Adoption of Improved Soil Fertility Management
How to cite
Butler, A; Mahajan, Aprajit. 2016. "Alleviating Constraints to Adoption of Improved Soil Fertility Management." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001200. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1200-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Smallholder farmers in low income countries often invest a large proportion of their production costs in fertilizer, however returns on this investment can be highly variable and maximum potential productivity gains are very rarely achieved (Beaman et al. 2013; Duflo et al. 2008; Suri 2011). Experimental evidence points to the need for balanced nutrient application in order to maximize the efficiency of each synthetic compound (Das et al. 2009). However in order to effectively optimize fertilizer use efficiency, targeted advice needs to be generated at the individual level based on current soil fertility status as well as the nutrient demands of the cropping system (Das et al. 2009). At present, most farmers rely on blanket fertilizer recommendations which fails to account for this variability. The emphasis on nitrogen based fertilizers also implies that the supply chains for other nutrients have not been well established. As a result even if farmers had the knowledge allowing them to adopt more effective fertilizer application practices, appropriate and timely supply of fertilizer may still remain a major constraint. Here we will investigate the constraints to adoption of a new affordable automated system for delivering balanced fertilizer recommendations as compared to government soil testing laboratories.
Intervention
The intervention to be piloted is the provision of fertilizer recommendations using both the automated NE system and a soil testing laboratory facility with and without time bound procurement of fertilizer to smallholder farmers in the state of Madhya Pradesh India. We will conduct the intervention during the winter (Rabi) growing season, as 80% of farmers cultivate wheat as the dominant crop and would therefore benefit from NE recommendations.
There are costs and benefits to these two alternative recommendation systems which need to be better understood. The automated NE system, is cheap and easily deployed in the field and can therefore reach a lot more clients in a shorter period of time. However the system focuses on the dynamic requirements of macro nutrients (N:P:K) throughout the growing season, while neglecting potential deficiencies in micro nutrients. In contrast, the soil testing laboratories are able to provide extremely accurate nutrient requirement, including micro nutrients. However, farmers must incur the cost of getting their soil tested. A comparison of these two alternative solution will provide us with valuable information on potential adoption rates, as well as the relative benefits to productivity.
Farmers in Madhya Pradesh commonly take out a loan from government cooperatives and purchase fertilizer within the same transaction. However, their choice of fertilizer is limited to those supplied at the cooperative outlet, which is in turn driven by coarse government recommendations. At the time of delivering our recommendations we will give the farmers a service through which we would source and deliver the precise recommended fertilizers in a timely manner. This should ease any existing market inefficiencies that may be restricting adoption.
Experimental design
This pilot study has two principle treatment arms. The first will be given NE fertilizer recommendations, while the other will be given recommendations from a soil testing laboratory. Within each of the two treatment groups a random half the farmers will be offered a guarantee of time bound fertilizer procurement.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.