Encouraging hands-on job experimentation among teenagers
How to cite
Delfino, Alexia; Brenoe, Anne; Schilter, Claudio; Wolter, Stefan. 2023. "Encouraging hands-on job experimentation among teenagers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011973. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11973-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Everywhere in the world, teenagers are asked to make educational choices which will have long-term consequences on their career trajectories and opportunities. Across OECD countries, students between 10 and 14 years old are asked to choose what school track to follow. While this choice is influenced by a number of people, tools which empower students to make a more informed choice are uncommon.
This study aims to understand how experimentation affects job search and career choices. We hypothesize that encouraging teenagers’ experimentation of different occupations will affect their job search and ultimately help them make better choices for their career. To the best of our knowledge, this will be the first study to examine how (forced) experimentation in a real-life work environment can affect students’ job search and, perhaps, their long-term career choices.
We design a randomized controlled trial (RCT) targeted to grade 8 students in Switzerland, of whom most will start an apprenticeship after compulsory education (i.e., after 9th grade). The intervention consists in enabling students to experience the real work environment in occupations they have not considered before. We collaborate with schools and firms. The intervention is part of a one-day school event where students visit 4-5 local firms to hear and learn about apprenticeships they have signed up for. For the project, we will introduce experimental variation in the type of occupations that a student experiences during these visits at the local firms.
Intervention
To test whether experimentation with the real-life work environment in non-considered occupations affects students’ occupational search, we designed the following intervention in collaboration with schools and firms in multiple towns in Switzerland. In each town, the school organizes a one-day school event (henceforth event) devoted to occupational choice. During this event, students visit 4-5 different firms where they get to experience one occupation in each firm. We refer to each of these visits as a trial apprenticeship (TA). In addition, students also attend 1-2 workshops during the event. Each TA and workshop have a time slot of around 50 minutes and are attended by a group of students.
Schools collaborate with local firms to create the TAs and the workshops. Before the event, students get a list of all available TAs in their town and indicate 5-6 occupations they would like to experience during the event. To coordinate all the visits, schools use a computer program with a specific algorithm to allocate students to firms based on students’ preferences and firms’ availability. The two workshops are typically unrestricted in size and work as a buffer to mitigate logistical difficulties in creating the program.
Students who are randomized into the control arm get to experience 4 TAs and 2 workshops; these 4 TAs are selected by the algorithm from the list of 5-6 occupations they indicated at signup. Thus, control students only get to experience occupations they are interested in. Students who are randomized into the treatment arm will similarly get to experience 4 TAs they signed up for and 1 workshop. On top of this, treated students will experience a 5th TA which they did not sign up for. In other words, the treatment is to experience an occupation they had not considered before. We categorize occupations based on their gender composition (female, neutral, male) and type (working with hands/machines, working with people, working with computer). Treatment occupations are randomly drawn from a category which is different to the categories of the students’ preferred occupations.
Experimental design
Randomization happens in two steps.
In the first step, we assign to all the students a “potential” treatment occupation in the following way. We consider the 5 to 6 occupations that the student ranks as their favourites and assign them to the corresponding occupational categories we defined. These are the categories that the student is interested in. To pick a treatment occupation, we randomly choose 2 of the occupational categories that the student is NOT interested in and select all the TAs in these two categories that are in the student’s own or an adjacent skill category. The student is then shown the list of TAs belonging to these two non-preferred categories and can veto up to two of these TAs. We then randomly select one TA among the non-vetoed TAs in these non-preferred categories to be the 5th TA which treated students experience during the event. We also pick a backup treatment-TA which we could use in case there is an organizational problem to use a specific TA. For specific deviations from these assignment rules, see the PAP.
In the second step, we then assign students to the treatment or control stratifying by school, classroom and gender.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.