Behavioral Interventions to decrease dangerous driving in Armenia

How to cite

Baghdasaryan, Vardan. 2023. "Behavioral Interventions to decrease dangerous driving in Armenia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011972. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11972-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Vardan Baghdasaryan*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011972
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11972-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-08-23 – 2023-10-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D04, I18, K42, R4
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11972

Abstract

With a population of around 3 million, Armenia has a high road fatality rate of 9.4 deaths per 100,000 people. In 2019, road crash fatalities were more than double the European Union (EU) average, and the socioeconomic costs of road crashes are estimated at 5.7 percent of Armenia’s GDP.
Within a wider context of road safety improvement projects in Armenia, the purpose of the current trial is to test whether messages using different behavioral framings cause any significant change in the driving behavior of the subjects concerned.

The specific research questions are:
- Is the communication with the drivers using the existing channels effective to deter risky driving behavior (in particular, speeding)?
- Do the drivers respond differently to messages which are designed to target different biases and themes?
- Does the information on relative position of the driver in terms of driving license points lost create incentives to change risky driving behavior?

The trail is aiming to run a behavioral randomized controlled trial that would address the research questions stated just above. It will utilize the existing infrastructure used by road police to communicate with the drivers about their performance.
The overall aim of the trial is to reduce the number of traffic rules violations with a specific emphasize on speed regime violations.

In this trial we will be implementing 2 different RCTs which utilize different communication means and intend to reach out to the drivers with the purpose of changing their risky driving behavior.

The first experiment will utilize the existing modes of communication used by road police to communicate with the drivers about their performance (mainly official letters). The second experiment will use additional SMS to be sent to the drivers.

Intervention

There are two types of interventions envisaged.
First one utilizes the system of notifying the drivers about traffic speeding rules violations by providing additional information to them (both paper based and electronic). There are 5 active treatment arms which differ by the messages and behavorial biases they are targeted at. In addition, the subjects are separated into 3 different blocks depending on previous history of speeding violations.
Second intervention is a stand alone SMS based communication with the registered drivers which provides an update about the traffic violation points preserved/lost at this point of time in the year. The messages are meant to trigger social comparisons and within subject comparisons of performance over time. There are 4 active treatment arms envisaged.
The Final goal is to induce change in driving behavior which will be statistically measurable. .

Experimental design

There are two types of interventions envisaged.
First one utilizes the system of notifying the drivers about traffic speeding rules violations by providing additional information to them (both paper based and electronic). There are 5 active treatment arms which differ by the messages and behavorial biases they are targeted at. In addition, the subjects are separated into 3 different blocks depending on previous history of speeding violations. In particular all drivers who have violations in 2021-2022, as well as first half of the 2023 are divided into three groups - with low number of violations (3-4 per year), medium (5-7 per year) and high (more than 7). The experiment is randomized for 5 active treatment arms for each of these blocks separately.

The second intervention is a stand alone SMS based communication with the registered drivers which provides an update about the traffic violation points preserved/lost at this point of time in the year. With this option we intend to use the point system introduced by the Road Police back in 2020, which provides the information about the driver’s performance via an electronic platform. Under this approach there is no need to wait for specific event to happen to be able to communicate with the experimental subjects. The communication can be chosen to happen at any time, using the contact details (mobile phone numbers) which are available in the system. The population of the drivers registered in the system as of the moment of the experiment (e.g. July 2023) will be block randomized into three active treatment arms and one control arm (which will receive no communication at all). The sample of the experiment participants and the allocation to treatment arms will be conducted in advance. The intervention will be delivered by the Road Policy using SMS and phone numbers identified in the database. Technical duration of intervention is very short (hours), but it would be preferable to monitor the delivery of the messages and conduct it over 2-3 days.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented using randtreat routine in Stata.
Randomization unit
Individual driver
Clusters
There are 3 blocks for each of the two interventions.
Observations
For each of the two experiments it is planned to send out around 10,000 notifications. Each of the experiments combined with control group will be composed of around 12,000 observations. This number might be not final due to specifics of the fieldwork.
Arms
Sample size is different depending on the blocks given that the power requirements can be different due to variations in means and standard deviations. Intervention 1. Block 1 - 450 per treatment - 2250 active + 450 control Block 2 - 550 per treatment - 2750 active + 550 control Block 3 - 700 per treatment - 3500 active + 750 control Note: Sample sizes are large due to the assumption of low delivery rate of the letters (1 out of 3 sent) and the differences in number of observations per treatment are due to larger standard deviation in Block 2 and Block 3. Intervention 2. Block 1 - 900 per treatment - 2700 active + 900 control Block 2 - 750 per treatment - 2250 active + 750 control Block 3 - 750 per treatment - 2250 active + 750 control Note: WE do not have reliable information to what extent the mobile numbers in the system are accurate. The sample size is relatively large due to assumption that 1 out of 2 numbers is correct and the message will be delivered. Relatively low cost of intervention (sending additional page with the intervention 1 adds almost zero marginal cost and the price of one SMS in Armenia is low as well) provides the opportunity to have conservative estimations of sample sizes.
Primary outcomes
For first intervention: Number of speed violations registered by speed cameras For second intervention: Number of violation points preserved/lost
Secondary outcomes
For first intervention: The days between two adjacent violations during the observation period
Sponsors
Name: UNDP SDG Lab Yerevan Location: Yerevan, Armenia Url: https://www.sdglab.am/
Partners
Name: UNDP SDG Lab Yerevan Partner_type: government Url: https://www.sdglab.am/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords