Bridging the Digital Divide: Data Access and Integration of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombia

How to cite

Vasquez-Cortes, Mateo; Asimovic, Nejla; Munger, Kevin. 2023. "Bridging the Digital Divide: Data Access and Integration of Venezuelan Migrants in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011945. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11945-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mateo Vasquez-Cortes* , Nejla Asimovic , Kevin Munger

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011945
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11945-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-08-28 – 2023-09-29
Countries
Colombia (Medellin, Cali, Cucuta, Berranquilla, Bogota)
JEL codes
F22; C93; D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11945

Abstract

Violence and the humanitarian crisis in Venezuela has led nearly two million Venezuelans to flee to Colombia (USAID 2020). Despite the growing efforts of the Colombian government to provide support, forcibly displaced and migrant populations continue to face various legal, economic, and social barriers. One of the many barriers relates to limited internet access which reduces the amount of information that the financially constrained migrants can obtain about government programs or economic opportunities, as well as limits their ability to expand or sustain their social ties. We assess the effects of enhanced data access (by providing mobile data credits) on migrants’ knowledge and interest about the existing migrant assistance programs, on the expansion and sustainment of their social networks, and on their levels of psychological wellbeing. Our design also allows us to test whether complementing enhanced data access with access to moderated WhatsApp groups which provide both legitimate information leads to better socio-economic outcomes for this community. Finally, we provide evidence of how levels of digital literacy within this community – captured through a novel set of literacy measures – shapes the effects of this intervention and the challenges related to migrant integration and wellbeing.

Intervention

The main intervention is the provision of a one-time monthly phone plan that also includes unlimited access to social media (e.g. WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter). Participants will of course be informed of the possibilities offered by the data package and the pages they can access for free.

In addition to data access, one treatment arm (subgroup of the sample) will also receive Whatsapp messages from IPA on behalf of the Colombian government with the aim of providing truthful information about Sisben, the database used for targeting social programs. Since the messages will be coming from an office of the Colombian government, we can ensure that the information circulated is accurate, fact-checked and useful for the community (e.g. request a Sisben survey or update their profile in the dataset).

A third treatment arm consists of participants which in addition to enhanced data access and messages received, will also be invited to participate in a Whatsapp group managed by IPA on behalf of the DNP, to provide them with more interaction with the information received about Sisben.

Experimental design

The mobile phone credit recharges given to all the treatment groups will be delivered using a service that allows for massive mobile phone top-ups of different phone providers. These recharges will be of around $30.000 COP (7 USD), and will give the participants’ unlimited access to social media, and additional GB for navigation. The specific amount of GB for navigation varies by provider.

For treatment #2 (access to internet + information via Whatsapp), IPA will use Twilio to send weekly messages with information approved by the National Planning Department. We will send 1-5 different messages weekly, which may include multimedia content. At any point, participants may express their desire to stop receiving these messages.

Treatment #3 (access to internet + information and interaction via Whatsapp groups): Participants in this treatment arm will be invited to participate in a Whatsapp group managed by IPA on behalf of the DNP, to provide them with more interaction with the information received about Sisben. These interactions will be as organic as possible, the group aims to be a space for users to communicate with one another if they choose so. These groups will have around 30 participants each. While the selection of the participants that fall into treatment #3 will be random, participants of each group will be created to have some characteristics in common according to Sisbén or the screening survey (for example, city of residence in Colombia, or state of origin in Venezuela).

A member of the research team will be in the group to ensure there is no discriminatory, hateful or toxic speech. The research team will not share participants’ name or phone number in connection with any of the messages. In case participants’ deviates too much from the desired topics of discussion (Sisbén, social programs, Venezuelans economic integration), a reminder will be sent to emphasize the objective of the group.

These messages and groups will be sent by IPA in collaboration with the National Planning Department and will provide information related to government services, with links to websites that data-capped users might otherwise not be able to visit. In particular, these messages will provide information about Portal Ciudadano Sisben, an online office through which citizens are able to perform several procedures about Sisben, the database of potential beneficiaries of social and economic programs in Colombia. These messages are approved by the National Planning Department, and have already been used in other communication campaigns by the government.

After the endline, the control group will receive the mobile phone credit recharge, and the control group and treatment 1 will receive all the information sent to the treatment 2 and 3 groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Given the pre-treatment information available from Sisen, we conduct a block randomization by age, gender, education level, and city. In the Sisben sample shared with us, there are 67,439 individuals from five municipalities, all of whom have temporary stay permits. Of the total sample, 64.22% are female, while 35.78% are male. The mean age is 36.82, with a median age of 34.35. Furthermore, 25.68% of the sample has an elementary school education level or no formal schooling, 61.18% has a high school education, and 13.14% holds a university degree or higher.
Randomization unit
Individual (Venezuelan migrant registered in Sisben)
Clusters
2000 individuals
Observations
2000 individuals
Arms
500 observations for each of the four groups (three treatment arms and one pure control group).
Primary outcomes
Venezuelan migrants’ in Colombia wellbeing and digital literacy. Knowledge of government programs. Trust in institutions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords