THE EFFECTS OF PERSONALIZED FEEDBACK: Replication in a non-pandemic context.
How to cite
Aucejo, Esteban; Wong, Kelvin. 2023. "THE EFFECTS OF PERSONALIZED FEEDBACK: Replication in a non-pandemic context.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011939. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11939-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study examines the effects of scalable, personalized email feedback on students at a large public institution in the US. We aim to discern which feedback types most significantly influence student learning and retention, specifically identifying the content that most likely alters student behavior. Our research closely mirrors the experiment presented in the working paper “The Effect of Feedback on Student Performance” by Esteban Aucejo and Kelvin Wong.
Our analysis seeks to validate these findings in an environment where the pandemic does not influence classes (Fall 2023). The pandemic led to diminished interactions between students and professors due to the reliance on platforms like Zoom for instruction. In such a scenario, personalized feedback emails might have held greater significance for students, potentially resulting in more pronounced effects.
We aim to evaluate the varied effects of feedback messages on three distinct student groups:
a) First-generation students (those whose parents did not attend college) versus non-first-generation students,
b) Over-optimistic students (defined by the disparity between their expected class rank and their rank after the first exam) versus their non-overoptimistic counterparts,
c) Mode of instruction students received: traditional in-person, hybrid, or online classes.
To gauge the influence of feedback, we will evaluate both educational outcomes and qualitative student responses. We will explore students' perceptions of personalized feedback messages and determine how their beliefs shift post-feedback.
Intervention
Students enrolled in introductory economics courses will receive personalized feedback emails based on their performance in the initial class exam. The distribution of these emails will be randomized yet stratified by factors such as first-generation status, gender, and letter grade achieved in the first exam. Additionally, we will conduct two surveys to collect background data and gauge any shifts in students' beliefs regarding their capabilities.
Experimental design
Students from a largepublic higher education institution, specifically those enrolled in economics courses, will receive varied feedback based on their exam results. The objective is to ascertain the impact of personalized feedback on student outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.