Experimenting for self and for others: farmer experimentation as a public good

How to cite

Ndegwa, Michael; Kariuki, Sarah; Michelson, Hope; Mbugua, Mercy; Maertens, Annemie; Chamberlin, Jordan; Donovan, Jason. 2023. "Experimenting for self and for others: farmer experimentation as a public good." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011937. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11937-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michael Ndegwa* , Sarah Kariuki , Hope Michelson , Mercy Mbugua , Annemie Maertens , Jordan Chamberlin , Jason Donovan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011937
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11937-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-01-30 – 2024-12-30
Countries
Kenya (Eastern and Western Kenya)
JEL codes
D81, D25, O12, O13, Q12, Q54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11937

Abstract

Farmer experimentation with new technologies is constant and fundamental to adoption, innovation, and climate adaptation. Even so, this experimentation often takes place in semi-private ways that limit the positive externalities of their effort and slows learning by others. We implement a village-level randomized controlled trial to evaluate three strategies to promote farmer experimentation and learning. We vary the proportion of farmers in a village to whom we offer maize seed trial packs, splitting the low concentration treatment arm to an incentive and non-incentive group. In 52 villages, 10% of villagers receiving trial packs of 0.5 kgs of maize. In 52 villages, 10% of the farmers receive packs plus incentives to compensate them for the knowledge that they generate. In a third arm of 52 villages 35% of the farmers receive trial packs. All participant farmers receive a sign to post next to their experimental field to mark their work. We study the relative effects of these treatment arms on effort by disseminating farmer, further experimentation by individual farmers, learning, perceptions and yield expectation, and adoption of new maize varieties. We use our design to test the effects of different levels of saturation within a village against a model where farmers are compensated for their experimental efforts.

Intervention

Our experiment involves distribution of maize seed trial packs and setting up of experimental plots by the randomly selected farmers. We vary the proportion of farmers in a village to whom seed trial packs are offered, splitting the low concentration treatment arm to an incentive and non-incentive group as below:
1) low concentration treatment: 10% of villagers receiving trial packs.
2) low concentration plus incentives treatment in which hosts will be compensated for participation, to evaluate the role of incentivizing host farmers to share information actively and intentionally with their fellow villagers.
3) high concentration treatment: 35% of villagers receiving trial packs.

Randomly selected households from the treatment villages were presented with trial packs of two preselected experimental maize varieties for them to endogenously select one. Below are the criteria used for selection of the experimental varieties:
1) they are relatively new varieties – at most 5-years and below since they were commercially released
2) they are preferred varieties for that locale, as recommended by breeders and agronomists working in that geographic area,
3) they are available in local markets BUT
4) are not yet widely used by local farmers (purchased by <10% of buyers?).

Randomly selected households from treatment villages were presented with 0.5kg maize seed packs. Seed distribution was conducted at the same time as baseline survey. this was accompanied by brief explanation on the trial protocol, which was also handed out to the participating farmers. All seed pack distributions were also accompanied by signs/varietal posters where the participating farmers were encouraged to display in the experimental plots.

Our study design will inform decisions concerning the proportion of farmers in a given area/region seed companies and other stakeholders should be distributing seed trial packs to and whether incentives are necessary to promote experimentation. These are important decisions given that scale directly affects marketing budgets for new varieties. Our work will measure the impacts of alternative promotion models on outcomes of interest at the farmer- and village-level, including awareness of new varieties, perceptions and beliefs about new varieties, demand and willingness to pay for new varieties.

Experimental design

Our treatments vary at cluster/village level. Treatments are defined at the village-level in order to evaluate village-level effects on awareness, perception and demand for experimental varieties. Our experimental design includes a control group and three treatment arms as defined below:
1) T1: Light treatment – this involves low saturation in terms of the proportion of farmers hosting the trials in a village. We endorsed 10% saturation level for this treatment arm. The randomly selected hosts were given 0.5kg of seeds to experiment with.
2) T2: Light treatment + incentives – we layer incentives to host farmers on top of T1. The hypothesis here is that incentivizing host farmers could encourage them to share information among their counterparts, which could then improve the effectiveness of trial packs model, even with low concentration. For the incentives, we are sending Ksh 1500 (approx. USD 11) to host farmers under this treatment arm in three instalments of equal amount.
3) T3: Heavy treatment – this involves high saturation of trial hosts in a village where 35% of households in a village host the trials of 0.5kg of seeds.
4) T0: Control – this is a comparison group where no intervention will be implemented.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in the office by the researchers using Stata.
Randomization unit
We employed cluster level randomization where treatments were assigned at village level
Clusters
208 villages
Observations
4,160 households
Arms
52 clusters control, 52 clusters treatment1 (low saturation), 52 clusters treatment2 (low saturation plus incentives), and 52 clusters treatment3 (high saturation)
Primary outcomes
• Willingness to experiment with new varieties • Varietal switching – from old well known to newer varieties. Measured as 1) Proportion of planted varieties that are new, 2) Proportion of maize area cultivated with new varieties, and 3) Weighted average age of varieties planted by a household. • Awareness and exposure to the specific varieties used in the study (experimental varieties)
Secondary outcomes
• Adherence to experimental recommendations (for trial hosts in treated villages) • trial hosts dissemination of experimental process and results • Perceptions about new varieties (vis-à-vis old known ones) on performance, quality and production costs • Expected yield distributions for new varieties vis-à-vis established ones (status quo)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords