Selection and impact in the sharing of stigmatized information

How to cite

Smith, Emma. 2023. "Selection and impact in the sharing of stigmatized information." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011928. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11928-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Emma Smith*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011928
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11928-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-08-15 – 2023-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11928

Abstract

This project aims to identify whether there is a trade-off in how individuals prefer to spread information about stigmatized services versus what is most effective at increasing message recipients’ take-up of stigmatized services. In particular, are people more willing to share information in dismissive (relative to sincere) ways, or a manner that makes their friend feel less singled out (relative to being targeted)? Is the recipient of a dismissive and/or general message less likely to choose to use the advertised services? This project studies the above questions in the context of peer referrals for a mental health phone counseling service for Syrian refugees.

Intervention

The experimental intervention consists of the manner in which the counseling helpline is introduced to participants. The four framings are designed to separately alleviate the sender's image concerns regarding sharing stigmatized information, and the recipient's image concerns regarding being targeted to receive information about a stigmatized service.

Experimental design

The experimental design is as follows:
1. Participants surveyed about their social network
2. Participants randomized to a particular framing/wording to introduce the counseling helpline
3. Participants asked which friends they want informed about the helpline if using the assigned framing.
4. Participants offered a financial incentive if they are willing to have the helpline introduced using different framings.
5. Recipients (friends of the original participant) who the original participant agreed to have contacted are contacted and introduced to the helpline using a randomly selected framing from within the framings the original participant consented to.
6. Recipients’ take-up of the helpline is measured.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Senders are randomized across all 4 framings at the sender-level. Recipients are randomized to framings at the recipient level, randomizing across the framings to which the sender consents.
Clusters
700 senders, with an expected average of 3 friends named per sender. The design of sender willingness to each recipient is clustered at the recipient level. 2100 recipients: Recipient treatment is not clustered.
Observations
700 senders, 2100 recipients
Arms
175 senders per framing arm 525 recipients per framing arm
Primary outcomes
Sender’s choice of whether the recipient will receive information about the helpline from the study. (Constructed as a recipient-level indicator variable taking 1 if the sender chooses the person in the subset of friends who should receive information about the helpline, and 0 for the sender’s friends who the sender does not select.) The recipient’s take-up of the helpline: Takes 1 if the recipient agrees that she wishes to be contacted by the helpline if found eligible (measured prior to completing the screening to confirm eligibility)
Secondary outcomes
Recipient’s self assessment of her distress: Standardized score of the recipient’s self assessment of her distress on a scale from 1 to 10 with 10 being the most distressed, standardized using the mean and standard deviation of Framing 1. Recipient’s self-assessment of the benefit she would gain from using the helpline: Standardized score of the recipient’s self-assessment of her distress on a scale from 1 to 10 if she were to start having weekly phone sessions with the helpline for 1 month, standardized using the mean and standard deviation of Framing 1. Recipient’s assessment of the distress that her friends believe she is experiencing: Standardized score of the recipient’s self-assessment, standardized using the mean and standard deviation of Framing 1. Recipient’s opinion of the ideal framing to use when communicating the helpline to someone who is uncomfortable with mental health services. - Indicator variable for preferring compensation framing over “want to share” framing. - Indicator variable for preferring “targeting my friends” framing over general friends framing. Accuracy of recipient’s self-assessment of the probability that she has anxiety or depression: An indicator variable taking 1 if and only if the recipient states she believes it is “likely” or “very likely” that she has experienced anxiety or depression in the past 2 months AND her PHQ-9 score or GAD-2 score indicates that she likely has depression or anxiety, using standard cutoffs. Recipient’s opinion that she should be able to solve her own mental health problems: Standardized score of likert variable, standardized using the mean and standard deviation of Framing 1. Recipient’s opinion that religious solutions are the best way to solve mental health problems: Standardized score of likert variable, standardized using the mean and standard deviation of Framing 1. Heterogeneities to be tested - Sender prior use of MH services - Sender wants to use the advertised helpline - Sender treatment status in prior experiment - Sender’s guess of the recipient’s distress level - Recipient’s depression and anxiety scores - Sender’s depression and anxiety scores - Recipient prior use of mental health services - Original framing under which the sender selected the recipient to get the information

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords