Whom do we listen to? Preferences in social learning
How to cite
Moorthy, Akshay. 2023. "Whom do we listen to? Preferences in social learning." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011924. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11924-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
People are known to egocentrically discount instrumentally valuable information acquired through social interactions. In this paper, I explore whether this is driven by preferences over the identity of information sources using online experiments where the identity of information sources and the value of information are exogenously assigned. The study focuses on caste identity in India, and asks whether people have preferences for information that are based on the caste identity of the information source.
Intervention
This is an experimental study on the role of social identity on the demand for information. The main idea is that information acquisition is driven by concerns for the accuracy for information, which is difficult to observe in many settings. In the context of information acquisition through social interactions, people may use an information provider's social identity to draw inferences about the quality or ability of the information. In this experiment, we aim to determine whether people possess preferences for information acquisition in a setting where social identity a salient and important part of everyday life - caste identity in India. The experiment is designed to control beliefs about the quality of information sources, which will allow for the identification of preferences for the identity of information sources.
Experimental design
Experimental task:
Participants need to estimate a probability (0-100) given the necessary information in a balls-and-urns paradigm. First, they make an independent estimate. Next, they are shown a number and asked if they want to stick to their decision or switch to the shown number. The shown number is correct with a given probability (the QUALITY of the information), else it is incorrect.
Participants complete 6 of these tasks, and all estimates are incentivised. Incentives are clearly communicated to participants, and all participants undergo a short training and comprehension module before starting the main experimental tasks.
Treatments:
The treatments manipulate the manner in which this number is shown in a 2x2 design. In treatment group Quality, information about the quality of the information (the probability with which the information is incentive maximising) is shown. In treatment group No Quality, this information is not shown. The quality is either 50%, or 90%, and is randomly chosen for each task. The values are selected from the responses to the same tasks in a previously conducted study.
The other arm of the 2x2 manipulates the caste identity. In treatment group G, the identity of the information source is a General caste category individual. In treatment group O, the identity of the information source is an individual who belongs to a caste group other than the general caste category.
Randomisation:
Randomisation is conditional only on the target sample size for each cell of the 2x2, details and sample sizes for each cell are provided below.
Incentives:
Incentives are calculated as follows: Participants make 6 independent estimates, and 6 SWITCH decisions. One of these 12 outcomes is randomly chosen for an incentive. If the estimate represented in the randomly chosen decision is within 2 percentage points of the Bayesian posterior, participants receive a bonus.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.