Role Models and gender gaps in vocational-technical high schools in Chile.

How to cite

Sevilla, Maria Paola; Madero, Cristobal; Cueva, Selene. 2023. "Role Models and gender gaps in vocational-technical high schools in Chile.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011902. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11902-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maria Paola Sevilla* , Cristobal Madero , Selene Cueva

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011902
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11902-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-06-05 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Chile ()
JEL codes
I23, I26, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11902

Abstract

Recent studies indicate that only one out of three female students persists in their chosen field when it is historically dominated by males, whereas male students persist at a rate of 70%. This research project uses an experimental approach to study the effects of incorporating female role models (role-model) in delivering information on educational and occupational alternatives related to Industrial Maintenance and Automation 4.0 among female students in vocational-technical high schools in Chile (EMTP by its acronym in Spanish) in the context of a middle-income country. The experiment involves a short-term intervention where male and female students from Electrical, Electronics, Industrial Mechanics, Automotive Mechanics, and Programming specializations in 80 EMTP institutions are introduced to the labor context, qualifications, and occupational profiles of the multisector of Industrial Maintenance and Automation 4.0. Furthermore, the students receive guidance on the associated educational and occupational pathways. In the “treatment” institutions, the information and guidance will include life stories of three female professionals who have built their educational and occupational careers from EMTP to the Industrial Maintenance and Automation 4.0 multisector. In the remaining “control" institutions, neutral gender-oriented information and guidance will be provided. We will study the effects of the exposure to role-models through video on educational aspirations and mechanisms such as gender stereotypes on women in EMTP careers.

Intervention

The experiment involves a short-term intervention where male and female students from Electrical, Electronics, Industrial Mechanics, Automotive Mechanics, and Programming specializations in EMTP institutions across Chile are introduced to the labor context, qualifications, and occupational profiles of the multisector of Industrial Maintenance and Automation 4.0. Furthermore, the students receive guidance on the associated educational and occupational pathways. The intervention content will be hosted on a restricted-access web platform to which the students will be invited to access.

Control Group: In the "control" institutions, neutral gender-oriented information and guidance about educational and occupational pathways are provided. The information is delivered through 4 sessions of 45 minutes with mini-informative videos about 1) Industry 4.0; 2) technical maintenance; 3) technological trends, and 4) Training-labor trajectories in technical maintenance. At the end of each session, the students were asked comprehension questions.

Treatment Group: Besides the information provided for the control group, the "treatment" institutions also receive information about the life stories of three young female professionals who have built their educational and occupational careers from EMTP to the Industrial Maintenance and Automation 4.0 multisector. After the videos, the participants also need to answer additional reflection questions about the role models' videos as part of the intervention.

Experimental design

The experiment includes the following stages:

1) Sample definition and invitation to participate in the study: All the EMTP schools in Chile that have at least 5 women students currently enrolled in the specializations of Electrical, Electronics, Industrial Mechanics, Automotive Mechanics, and Programming in 3rd and 4th year of high school were invited to be part of the study. Schools that accepted to cooperate will continue with the experiment.

The enrollment of schools has been done through 2 rounds. The rounds were divided based on the time of confirmation of each school.

2) Randomization: This study conducted clustered randomization by schools, assigning half of the schools to be part of the treatment group and the other half to the control group.

3) Access to the platform and baseline: The intervention content is hosted on a restricted-access web platform to which the students will be invited to access. The participants access it with their individual accounts created for the project. There, they first answer questions about sociodemographic background, the perception of the participants about the labor EMTP market, support, and others.

4) Intervention: During 4 sessions of 45 min, the participants watch the intervention of their respective group.

5) Endline: In the last session, after one or two weeks the intervention is finalized, the participants will answer the endline questionnaire.

Design details

Randomization method
We assign treatment status using a computer-based random number generation process after the schools accept to participate in the study. The stratified randomization uses these variables: capital, type of school, and round of participation, to create the strata.
Randomization unit
The level of randomization is the school.
Clusters
We expect about 90 schools.
Observations
Woman: 500. Men: 1790.
Arms
45 schools in the treatment group 45 schools in the control group
Primary outcomes
• STEM Career Aspirations • Implicit bias toward women in STEM higher education programs or careers • Enrollment in STEM higher education programs (long-run outcome)
Secondary outcomes
• Stereotype endorsement • Expectations toward a career in STEM fields • Expectations towards a work position in STEM fields • Engagement toward the career. • Attitude towards the career. • Self of belonging toward the career.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords