Morality Meets Risk: Predicting Others’ Excuse-Driven Behaviors
How to cite
DONG, Wanxin; Zheng, Jiakun. 2023. "Morality Meets Risk: Predicting Others’ Excuse-Driven Behaviors." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011896. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11896-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While individuals often engage in morally right actions, they prioritize their self-interest over moral considerations. Previous research has shown that people often manipulate information processing to rationalize their egoistic behavior, using situational uncertainties as excuses to justify their choices. However, a crucial issue is whether individuals can recognize the excuse-based actions of others. The research investigates individuals’ ability to predict others’ behavior in risky decision-making. In our laboratory experiment, participants make a decision task and a prediction task. The decision task will assess participants’ excuse-driven risk preferences, while the prediction task will delve into their predictions regarding others’ behaviors under the same risk scenario. Our hypothesis suggests that individuals possess the capacity to anticipate the excuse-driven behavior of others, but they may underestimate the intensity of self-interested actions exhibited by their peers.
Intervention
The experiment consists of two parts and adopts a within-subject design. The first part is a decision task for subjects to elicit their excuse-driven risk preferences. The second part is a prediction task to investigate participants’ predictions of others’ excuse-driven behavior under the same risk scenario. Two parts are presented in random order at the individual level.
In each part, there are four blocks of decision tasks including 12 price lists. Price lists in each block only differ in 3 different probabilities, i.e. {90%, 50%, 10%}, and four blocks are presented in a random order for each participant. The price lists include similar decisions as elaborated in Dong and Zheng (2023).
Experimental design
Building upon the work of Dong and Zheng (2023), we conduct a laboratory experiment consisting of two essential parts: a decision task and a prediction task. The decision task will assess participants’ excuse-driven risk preferences, while the prediction task will delve into their predictions of others’ excuse-driven behavior under the same risk scenario. In the decision task, participants complete a series of price lists involving risk. The price lists include similar decisions as elaborated in Exley (2016). Participants’ choices reveal their certainty equivalences of different lotteries such that we can estimate their excuse-driven risk preferences. In the prediction task, participants face the same decision tasks as in the decision task. Instead of making decisions for themselves, participants are asked to predict the responses to these tasks by other participants in their session. Two parts are presented in random order at the individual level.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.