The effect of receiving free educational support on the propensity to volunteer among secondary school students: An RCT in rural Bangladesh.

How to cite

Zaman, Anika; Islam, Asad; Wang, Liang Choon; Xia, Xing. 2023. "The effect of receiving free educational support on the propensity to volunteer among secondary school students: An RCT in rural Bangladesh.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011894. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11894-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anika Zaman* , Asad Islam , Liang Choon Wang , Xing Xia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011894
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11894-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-07-03 – 2024-08-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J22, O15, I21
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11894

Abstract

This study aims to examine if recipients of free educational support become more inclined to engage in volunteer activities and the impact of volunteering on well-being. We focus on secondary school students in rural Bangladesh who have received free educational audio lessons in a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT). We will measure their propensity to volunteer and elicit their preferences for volunteer activities. We also introduce a new RCT which randomly assigns volunteering invitation among the subset of students who sign up for volunteer activities. We use this new RCT to disentangle the effects of receiving IVR free educational support from the effects of participation in volunteer activities on students’ well-being.

Intervention

The ongoing RCT (AEARCTR - 0010647) primarily evaluates the effects of a free Interactive Voice Response (IVR) educational intervention on students' educational achievements and aspirations. This IVR education experiment was implemented between January 2023 and June 2023. In contrast, our study intends to examine whether the IVR educational intervention affects children’s inclination to volunteer. We do so by conducting an additional post-intervention survey in September 2023. In this follow-up survey, we: (1) measure students' propensity to volunteer using the “Bales Volunteerism-Activism Scale” questionnaire (Bales, 1996); and (2) elicit students’ preferences for volunteering through a “sign-up sheet” for actual volunteer activities. In October 2023, we will randomly assign invitation to volunteering activities to half of
the students who have signed up. Finally, a post-volunteering survey will be conducted in November 2023.

Experimental design

We use the experimental design of an existing RCT. The existing IVR education experiment (AEARCTR - 0010647) used a two-stage cluster randomized controlled trial with three experimental arms (two treatment arms and one control arm). In this RCT, 208 secondary schools were selected from a list of schools in the sub districts where the implementing organization, Global Development Research Institute (GDRI), operates.
In the first stage, these 208 schools were randomly allocated to one of three experimental arms (without stratification): T1 (self-help group), T2 (assisted group), and the control group. Each of the treatment arms (T1 and T2) comprises 69 schools, while the control group includes 70 schools. In the second stage, within-school randomization was conducted to select a subgroup of 9th grade students within T1 and T2 schools to receive the treatment. 15 students were selected on average per school. The students assigned to the ‘Self-help’ group (T1) were provided audio lessons which could be accessed through the IVR system by calling a registered phone number anytime during the 6-month intervention period. The students assigned to the ‘Assisted’ group (T2) received biweekly phone calls from a tutor to discuss the content covered in the IVR audio lessons in addition to access to the IVR audio lessons. The students in the control group did not receive any intervention.

The experimental design contains three study arms:
a) T1: Self-help group (69 schools, 1058 students) –was provided with information on how to access IVR-based lessons and how this program could result in improved educational outcomes (such as higher marks on the SSC exams). Participants will receive regular text messages from the IVR system.
b) T2: Assisted group (69 schools, 1022 students) – received the same information as students in T1. Additional treatment will be provided in the form of biweekly phone calls from a tutor. Participants will also receive regular text messages from the IVR system.
c) T3: Control (70 schools, 1050 students) - did not receive any intervention.
The focus of our study is to use the existing RCT design to examine the inclination to volunteer among students in the treatment and control groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer using Stata/BE 17.0
Randomization unit
A two-stage randomization procedure was employed. In particular, randomly selected 208 schools were assigned to two treatment groups and one control group, and then within each school 15 students on average were randomly selected (in a way that ensures almost equal numbers of boys and girls) from each of the 208 schools (for treatment in the treatment schools, and for data collection in the control schools).
Clusters
208 Schools
Observations
3,130 pupils
Arms
T1: Self-help group: 69 schools (units of randomization), 1058 students (units of observation) T2: Assisted group: 69 schools (units of randomization), 1022 students (units of observation) Control: 70 schools (units of randomization), 1050 students (units of observation)
Primary outcomes
Outcome Variables 1. Primary outcomes from the post-IVR survey 1.1 Propensity to volunteer Propensity to volunteer will be assessed using two instruments: “Bales Volunteerism-Activism Scale” and a “sign-up sheet”. 1.1.1 Bales Volunteerism-Activism Scale 1.1.2 Sign-up sheet 1.2 Preference over volunteer tasks 2. Primary outcomes from the post-volunteer survey 2.1 Attendance and participation in actual volunteer activities 2.2 Students’ well-being 2.3 Self-perceived happiness in comparison to others
Secondary outcomes
3. Secondary outcomes from the post-IVR survey 3.1 Helping with household chores. 3.2 Dimensions of volunteer attitude 3.2.1 A sense of effectiveness 3.2.2 Sociability and generability 3.2.3 Idealism or philosophical commitment 3.2.4 The ‘feel good’ factor 4. Secondary outcomes from the post volunteer intervention survey 4.1 Motivation to volunteer 4.2.1 Value 4.2.2 Understanding 4.2.3 Social 4.2.4 Career 4.2.5 Protective 4.2.6 Enhancement 4.3 Life satisfaction and perceived health condition 4.3.1 Perceived health 4.3.2 Life Satisfaction

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords