Persuasive Conversations: the relative importance of narratives and a non-judgmental exchange for reducing exclusionary attitudes
How to cite
Khan, Sana; Paluck, Elizabeth; Zeitlin, Andrew. 2023. "Persuasive Conversations: the relative importance of narratives and a non-judgmental exchange for reducing exclusionary attitudes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011880. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11880-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Recent research suggests that perspective-getting (i.e. listening to the personal narrative of another) when embedded in a bundled intervention improves feelings towards minoritized others and reduces exclusionary attitudes towards them in real world settings. These bundled interventions, however, contain other psychological components, such as creating an opportunity for introspection and sharing of one's own perspective or story or creating a non-judgmental environment for an exchange of perspectives, which could have an independent impact on feelings towards the other or on prejudicial attitudes. In the current study, we investigate the impact of three different stand-alone psychological interventions (perspective-getting; analogic perspective-taking, i.e. sharing one's own related experience or story to understand the perspective of the other; and, an exchange of reasons/perspectives in a non-judgmental environment) relative to a control group and to one another to understand the absolute and relative importance of narrative and of a non-judgmental exchange for prejudice reduction towards refugees. The setting for our study is Nairobi, Kenya. We examine the impact of these interventions on feelings and attitudes towards refugees as our primary outcomes of interest immediately after the intervention and 3 and 6 months from when the intervention is administered.
Intervention
1. Study participants in the control condition are only administered the measurement component of the survey experiment.
2. Study participants in the rhetorical exchange research arm engage in an exchange with the enumerator conducting the survey. The exchange begins with the enumerator asking the respondent to elaborate on/give reasons for their response to their feelings toward either Somali or Congolese refugees on a feelings thermometer (0-100 scale). Irrespective of the participants' response, the enumerator thanks them for sharing their reasons, explains why the enumerator thinks it is important to have this conversation, and offers to share their own reasons for how they feel. This research arm is meant as a non-judgmental exchange focusing on reasons without any personal narrative component or argumentation, at least by design.
3. Study participants assigned to the perspective-getting research arm listen to a personal narrative of a Somali or Congolese refugee living in Nairobi narrated by the enumerator. The narrative talks about the circumstances under which the individual/refugee left their home country, their separation from their family, their journey and the hardship they have experienced establishing themselves in this new location separated from their loved ones. Similar to the other active research arms, at the end of the personal narrative, the enumerator offers a summary of why they think it is important to listen to the perspective of others.
4. Study participants assigned to the analogic perspective-taking research arm, the enumerator asks the participant to recall a story from their own experience of a time they felt unsafe or felt like they were not in control of their life. If the participant does not have a personal story to share, the enumerator encourages them to recall the experience of a loved one. The enumerator engages the participant in an exchange about what that experience felt like for the respondent. At the end of the respondents' personal narrative, the enumerator draws a parallel from the respondents' story to the experiences of others, including refugees. Similar to the other active research arms, at the end of the exchange, the enumerator offers a summary of why they think it is important to have these kinds of conversations.
Experimental design
We utilize the structure of the ongoing RCT to conduct stratified random assignment at the level of the individual for this study. By RCT cohort (6 total), we stratify on original (RCT) treatment assignment, "role" type in original RCT (mentor or mentee) and gender and randomly assign participants to one of four research arms with equal assignment probability: (i) control; (ii) rhetorical exchange; (iii) perspective-getting; and (iv) analogic perspective-taking. For the rhetorical exchange and perspective-getting arms, stratifying on gender and "role", we further randomly assign participants to a specific nationality (either Congolese or Somali) refugee target with equal assignment probability. The study is rolled out on a cohort by cohort basis given the 3-month data collection timeline for the RCT.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.