Donating for Life-saving Medical Treatments: Need-Based or Merit-Based

How to cite

Chen, Junhao. 2023. "Donating for Life-saving Medical Treatments: Need-Based or Merit-Based." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011874. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11874-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Junhao Chen*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011874
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11874-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-08-03 – 2023-09-15
Countries
China (Online)
JEL codes
D64, I26, I14
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11874

Abstract

This paper studies how donors respond to merit and need when giving to families facing unaffordable medical expenses. With data from a leading Chinese crowdfunding platform, I find that campaigns receive more donations if fundraisers report attending higher-ranked colleges. By controlling for textual characteristics and exploiting within-donor variation at the transaction level, I show that donors favor patients who attend better colleges, and moderately favor ill family members of a college-attending fundraiser. In line with the donor's limited information about college rank, the residual rank effect is more pronounced for the top institutions and is muted for out-of-province ones.

I design an online RCT to elicit respondents’ willingness to donate to 20 synthetic fundraising stories. The college tier of the patients and requested donation amounts will be independently randomized. Incentives a la Kessler et al. (2019) will be provided to ensure truthful reporting. I expect respondents with better knowledge of college ranking would be more responsive to patients' college attendance.

Intervention

In each fundraising vignette shown to the respondents, I randomize story components while keeping the body of the vignette constant. The randomized components are 1) the college tier and 2) the amount of medical expenses that have occurred or are required. Treatments are randomized at the question-respondent level.

Experimental design

This RCT aims to identify if people prefer helping people with merit and/or in need. I formulate 16 synthetic vignettes based on actual fundraising stories. Within each vignette, I randomize two story components, the college tier and the amount of medical expenses that have occurred or are required. Treatments are randomized at the question-respondent level. Then I elicit willingness to donate to the patient in the vignette from respondents by asking directly (how much would they like to donate). The respondents report their willingness to donate between CNY 0-20 by scrolling a bar. An Incentive scheme a la incentivized resume rating (Kesler et al. 2019) is designed to ensure attention and truthful reporting.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done by the survey platform Credamo. It assigns 1 content pair out of 9 possibilities to each respondent for each question with an even possibility. However, it does not ensure sample size balance across arms. But on the whole, a roughly equal number of treatments are assigned when pooling all questions.
Randomization unit
Only one level of randomization. Randomization is realized at a question-participant level.
Clusters
Wave1: 16 vignettes of medical fundraising for a young patient with college attendance (half current student, the other half recent graduates) Wave 2: 16 vignettes where a young adult with college attendance fundraises for her ill senior family member. (Half of the young adults are current students, and the other half are recent graduates)
Observations
500 respondents in each wave. A total of 500*16 = 8000 questions would be answered.
Arms
The main body of each question (the vignette) would stay constant for every survey participant, while two treatments (story content) are independently randomized at the participant level. The first is a merit treatment of three tiers of college: 1) top 40 colleges, 2) colleges ranked 100-300, and 3) 4-year colleges ranked 500-800. The second is a need treatment of three categories representing medical expense (spent or required) above/around/below the average amount. There are 9 combinations of treatments, Thus for each question, roughly 55 participants out of 500 would be allocated in each arm for each question.
Primary outcomes
Self-reported willingness to donate to each synthetic fundraising vignette with randomized components (college tier and expenses occurred)
Sponsors
Name: Boston University, Institute for Economic Development Location: Boston , MA Url: https://www.bu.edu/econ/research/ied/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords