Reducing Non-Institutional Fraud and Building Trust in a Digital Market Platform: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Nigeria
How to cite
King, Michael; Putman, Daniel; Jang, Chaning. 2023. "Reducing Non-Institutional Fraud and Building Trust in a Digital Market Platform: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011872. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11872-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The high prevalence of digital financial fraud makes it difficult for businesses to distinguish between real communications from digital service providers and fraudulent communication. This could lead to a lack of trust in, and usage of digital financial services. Through a field experiment and a combination of administrative data and self-reported responses, we test two strategies for preventing non-institutional fraud: an anti-fraud campaign and a technical intervention – a unique communications code – which verifies the provenance of messages sent from a digital platform. First, we assess whether these anti-fraud interventions reduce susceptibility to fraudulent communications, and confidence in one’s ability to avoid fraud. Second, we test how these interventions affect trust in, and usage of financial services. We analyze how these impacts differ within key subgroups, including by demographic characteristics, socio-economic status, and risk preferences. Findings from this study will help improve consumer protection and support digital security in the financial and non-financial service sectors.
Intervention
MSEs will be randomised into one of three groups; a control, a financial education arm, or the UCC arm.
Control - This group will receive the compliance calls as standard procedure.
Treatment 1 - T1 participants will receive three compliance calls (every two months) which will include information about the five key signs of potential fraud which is narrated in an audio file. Participants will listen to an audio recording presenting key warning signs to look out for to identify fraud. To test their understanding of the recording, participants will be presented with two fraudulent or genuine communication scenarios and are asked what they would do in each scenario. The call centre agent will explain the correct answers. Immediately after the call participants will receive a follow up SMS summarizing the key warning signs.
Treatment 2 - This group will receive the same basic compliance calls as the treatment and control groups and will be informed about their unique communication codes. They will:
● Be introduced to the UCC system.
● Be assigned a randomly generated and recorded centrally 5-digit UCC code to authenticate future communications with Amana Market.
● Immediately after the call participants will receive a follow up SMS with their unique code to look out for in all future communication from Amana Market.
Experimental design
All participants are randomized into either a control group, an embedded anti-fraud focused financial literacy intervention or the unique communications code (UCC) group. The recruitment process involves two distinct groups: existing users and newly onboarded users within CoAmana. Each group initially aimed to achieve a target sample size of 1,800 individuals. The sampling pool was derived from three key states of operation: Kano, Kaduna, and Jigawa, which represent the primary regions of CoAmana's activities.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.