Relational Sourcing and Tree Rejuvenation Schemes in the Rwanda Coffee Sector

How to cite

Steenkamp, Iris; Singh, Ameek; Macchiavello, Rocco. 2023. "Relational Sourcing and Tree Rejuvenation Schemes in the Rwanda Coffee Sector." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011838. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11838-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Iris Steenkamp* , Ameek Singh , Rocco Macchiavello

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011838
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11838-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-07-10 – 2024-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D22, L14, O13, Q13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11838

Abstract

The beneficial impact of tree rejuvenation on yields is well established in the agronomic literature. Practitioners seem to recognize that the real challenge – particularly in the East African context – is to increase the adoption of rejuvenation practices, as those often entail significant upfront costs and foregone incomes, for rewards that kick in only in the future. This is a problem faced in many other contexts in which poor farmers are supposed to undertake costly investment to increase adaptation and resilience to climate change. In partnership with a leading coffee exporter, we design, implement, and evaluate the impact of incentive schemes and a digital information intervention on tree stumping behaviour by farmers in the Rwanda coffee chain. We embed financial incentive schemes within pre-existing sourcing relationships between our partner and coffee farmers in Rwanda.

Intervention

In partnership with a leading coffee exporter, we design, implement and evaluate the impact of incentive schemes on tree stumping behaviour by farmers in the Rwanda coffee chain. In both schemes, farmers receive financial incentives for stumping based on the number of trees they stump. Conditions and timing of payment vary across the different schemes.

Across three related experiments, we first examine the take-up of schemes and the choice of scheme by farmers. Second, we evaluate the effectiveness of different schemes on the adoption of tree-stumping practices. Third, we evaluate the role of a relationship-building program on the choice of scheme and the effectiveness of schemes. Additionally, we cross-randomize a digital intervention and evaluate its effectiveness in improving take-up of schemes and adoption of tree rejuvenation.

In this (pilot) project, we roll out a tree stumping intervention in seven coffee washing stations (CWS) in Rwanda. The intervention builds on an earlier pilot (AEARCTR-0008725) in which we set up a farmer development program (FDP) aimed to build trusting relationships between coffee farmers and the company.

Experimental design

This study partly builds on an earlier pilot in which we designed and evaluated a farmer development program (FDP) aimed at building relationships between farmers and the company.

Across three related experiments, our empirical strategy focuses on the following elements: i) take-up of tree rejuvenation schemes, ii) the (differential) impact of tree rejuvenation incentive schemes on tree stumping, iii) the impact of FDP on the effectiveness of choice and take-up of scheme, and iv) the effect of a digital support intervention.

We stratify random assignment within each individual CWS and over phone ownership, gender, FDP status, traceability indicators, and distance to CWS and relative distance to partner and other competitors.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer using software STATA.
Randomization unit
Randomization was individual Farmer-level for all treatments. Experiment A - Farmers were stratified by the following: “CWS X Intensity of FDP in Zone X Gender X FDP Tier X Certification Survey Done X Clarity-Credibility Calls Receipt X Relative Distance to Partner’s Coffee Collection Site X Relative Distance to Competitor’s CWS” Experiment B - Farmers were stratified by the following: “CWS X Intensity of FDP in Zone X Gender X Certification Survey Done X Clarity-Credibility Calls Receipt X Phone Ownership X Relative Distance to Partner’s Coffee Collection Site X Relative Distance to Competitor’s CWS” Experiment C - Farmers were stratified by the following: “CWS X Intensity of FDP in Village X Gender X FDP Eligibility (=0,1,2) X FDP Tier X Certification Survey Done X Clarity-Credibility Calls Receipt X Phone Ownership X Relative Distance to Partner’s Coffee Collection Site X Relative Distance to Competitor’s CWS” Additionally, in experiment C, FDP Status was randomized at individual level in January 2023.
Clusters
1
Observations
Experiment A: 1477 farmers Experiment B: 1482 farmers Experiment C: 3045 farmers
Arms
Experiment A: T1: 377 T2: 374 T3: 367 T4: 359 Experiment B: C: 767 T1: 344 T3: 371 Experiment C: 3045 farmers Choice only: 1522 Choice + Tx: 1523
Primary outcomes
1. Take-up of scheme 2. Choice of scheme 3. Adoption of tree stumping & number of trees stumped
Secondary outcomes
1. Coffee cherry delivery (KG) 2. Trust in CWS and Partner 3. Take-up of Lime & Fertilizer

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords