Improving Access to Finance

How to cite

Annan, Francis. 2023. "Improving Access to Finance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011825. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11825-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Francis Annan*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011825
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11825-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-06-01 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11825

Abstract

Access to finance remains a crucial barrier for economic development, particularly in rural areas lacking formal financial institutions. In the absence of formal financial institutions, Village Savings and Loans Associations (VSLAs) have emerged to partially fill the void, providing limited, informal financial services to their few select members. How might we design and improve access to finance in these markets with latent demand for financial services? In a randomized experiment with the largest service providers in Sierra Leone, we (i) "upgrade" VSLAs to operate as providers of retail mobile money and bank agents across rural unserved, virgin communities. We cross-randomize this with a (ii) feedback mechanism, letting consumers "evaluate" their providers monthly. We then measure effects on broader access to finance, households, and business outcomes, including on consumer satisfaction, complementary effects (if any) on VSLAs, behavior of providers, and the relationship between providers and consumers.

Indeed, connecting rural unserved, virgin communities with latent demand for retail digital financial services (DFS) is an important first order policy and commercial question. Perhaps, more important and distinct is our ability to improve the new markets once communities are connected. This project addresses major gaps in research about improving access to finance with (i) original data collection — on household, community, and business outcomes — and (ii) a multi-year community-level field experiment testing a scalable approach to retail agent expansions, VSLAs-as-agents. We follow the success of our 2019/2020 detailed pilot work to launch a full RCT in rural Sierra Leone—a market environment that is poorly studied—to answer the following two research questions:

1) RQ1. What are the broader, general equilibrium impacts of connecting unserved, virgin communities with retail DFS?
2) RQ2. Once connected, could letting consumers evaluate their providers improve the quality of services, consumer usage and satisfaction, provider effort, provider-customer relationships, and business outcomes, and if so, how?

In a unique collaboration with Catholic Agency for Overseas Development (CAFOD), Orange Money, GT Bank, and Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) - Sierra Leone, we implement a large-scale community-level field experiment that encourage Village Savings and Loan Associations (VSLAs) to set up and operate as retail DF agents across rural unserved communities in Sierra Leone. Agents or providers are established to offer both mobile money (via Orange Money) and bank services (via GT Bank) in 3 separate phases that span 2022-2024. This is an environment where the penetration of DFS is extremely low and retail agents or providers of formal finance are “non-existent” in these rural communities, but with latent demand and supply for DFS.

Intervention

The study will include two interventions meant to connect unserved communities to retail agents. First, to examine the broader impacts of providers of formal finance expansions, we encourage and onboard existing VSLAs as agents (VSLAs-as-agents) in randomly selected communities (Treatment I). Second, to test improvements in quality of services, consumer protection practices and consumer usage of DFS, we additionally implement a simple, anonymized feedback mechanism that provides monthly consumer feedback—based on digitized new user reviews or evaluations—to retailers and the community in a random set of connected communities (Treatment II). We implement monthly consumer evaluations and feedback loops to providers.

Experimental design

We explore two experimental variations:
(i) randomized entry of VSLAs-as-retail agents (Treatment I: i.e., upgrade VSLAs to operate as providers of formal finance) and
(ii) randomized entry of VSLAs-as-retail agents, combined with a consumer feedback mechanism (Treatment II).

*Control communities (Status Quo): No introduction of DF-retail agents or consumer feedback mechanism. (n=50 communities/VSLAs);

*Treatment I: To examine the broader impacts of retail agent expansions, we encourage existing VLSAs in select communities to enroll and operate as retail agents for both Orange Money and GT Bank only. (n=75 communities/VSLAs);

*Treatment II: To test improvements in quality of services and consumer usage in DFS, we additionally implement a simple, anonymized feedback mechanism that provides consumer feedback to enrolled retailers and connected communities. (n=75 communities/VSLAs).

Design details

Randomization method
Computer software and simple lotteries, while ensuring balance on baseline characteristics (Bruhn and McKenzie 2009), using baseline information gathered on the communities and VSLAs by our partner CAFOD.
Randomization unit
Randomization of treatments is at the community-level, stratified based on population of community (high vs low) and number of existing businesses in village (high vs low), yielding 4 unique strata, and all misfits (if any) resolved and randomly assigned.
Clusters
200 communities
Observations
*200 communities x 15 households / community members (respondent: hh head or customer) = 3,000 hh surveys; *200 communities x 1 VSLA (respondents: agent and secretary) = 200 businesses; *Customer reviews surveys: 75 review communities x 30 DF customers each x 3 rounds = 6,750 review surveys; *Supplemental administrative data from partner commercial providers (Orange/GT Bank) and CAFOD’s agent monitoring tools - 150 (treatment) communities
Arms
Control (Status Quo): n=50 communities/VSLAs; Treatment I: n=75 communities/VSLAs; Treatment II: n=75 communities/VSLAs.
Primary outcomes
For RQ1, we will compare the various Treatments versus Control. o Key outcomes: (i) take-up (0/1 indicator for sustained presence of retail agent in community); (ii) % of people that use financial/DF services (access); (iii) % of people that engage in money management, such as savings, budgeting, and loan management (utilization and/or knowledge); (iv) enterprise and VSLA groups sales revenue, number of customers, labor supply (operational hours), business income, assets, and business expenses (enterprise development); (v) services/DFS quality; (vi) women/adolescents’ empowerment and agency, including downstream outcomes; (vii) household expenses/consumption; (viii) shocks mitigation; (ix) poverty at the community level; (x) local multiplier (and velocity of money); (xi) similar outcomes under RQ2 below. For RQ2, we will compare Treatments 1 versus 2. o Key outcomes: (i) services/DFS quality (prices, transparency, reliability, customer service); (ii) consumers usage of DFS; reported happiness; well-being; perceptions/views; (iii) business income/outcomes; (iv) relationship between providers and consumer. (v) similar outcomes under RQ1 above. These broader impacts allow us to measure general equilibrium effects: (i) direct effects (businesses /VSLAs) and (ii) indirect effects (households e.g., consumption expenditure, shocks mitigation; vs community e.g., poverty, local multiplier; vs providers e.g., revenues).
Sponsors
Name: ReFinD Research Initiative Url: https://refind-isser.ug.edu.gh
Partners
Name: Catholic Agency for Overseas Development (CAFOD) Partner_type: ngo Url: https://cafod.org.uk Name: GT Bank Partner_type: private_company Url: https://www.gtb.sl Name: Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) - Sierra Leone Partner_type: ngo Url: https://poverty-action.org/sierraleone

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords