Financial Incentives to Shift Electric Vehicle Charging: Time-of-Use versus Managed

How to cite

Myers, Erica; Shaffer, Blake; Bailey, Megan; Brown, David; Wolak, Frank. 2023. "Financial Incentives to Shift Electric Vehicle Charging: Time-of-Use versus Managed." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011822. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11822-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Erica Myers* , Blake Shaffer , Megan Bailey , David Brown , Frank Wolak

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011822
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11822-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-01-17 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L94, Q48, D12, Q58
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11822

Abstract

As electric vehicle penetration increases it will stress the capacity of local distribution networks. This study is designed to assess the potential to shift electric vehicle (EV) charging times to reduce strain on the distribution system. We consider two approaches, 1) time of use pricing—offering a discount for individuals to charge in the off-peak hours and 2) managed charging—offering a per-kwh discount for consumers to let a 3rd party software to schedule charging times throughout the charging session to reduce the distribution network peak. We also assess individuals’ willingness to accept joining an incentive program for shifting charging and whether this varies with experience with managed charging.

Intervention

Phase 2: The treatments will include: i) Time-of-use (TOU), monetary incentives (payments) based on kWh charged during "off-peak" hours and ii) Managed, monetary incentives (payments) based on kWh charged when the vehicle is available to have its charging managed centrally.

Phase 3: The treatment will be a one-time randomized incentive for participants to opt-in to an incentive program for shifting vehicle charging for a defined additional period (e.g. 6 months).

Experimental design

Phase 1: Our utility partner will recruit willing customers to participate in the trial. This will be done through a media campaign, where willing customers can elect to participate in the trial. Participants will enroll in a 3rd party software that can monitor and managing EV charging.
Phase 2: Our utility partner and UCalgary/UAlberta researchers will randomize participants into treatment and control by distribution group. The treatments will include: i) Time-of-use (TOU), monetary incentives (payments) based on kWh charged during "off-peak" hours and ii) Managed, monetary incentives (payments) based on kWh charged when the vehicle is available to have its charging managed centrally.
Phase 3: All participants will be asked if they wish to opt-in to an incentive program for shifting charging for defined additional period (e.g. 6 months or a year) in exchange for a one-time financial reward. The utility partner and UCalgary/UAlberta will randomize financial incentives offered to households independent of Phase 2 treatment status.
All participants will receive a monetary payment ($150) for participating in the study, regardless of treatment or control group status. This payment will be 50% upfront, and 50% at the end.

Design details

Randomization method
Office computer
Randomization unit
Phase 2: distribution group level randomization Phase 3: household level randomization
Clusters
20 (start of the study) to up to 28 (if additional vehicles enroll) distribution groups
Observations
The number of observations will vary by vehicle according to when they downloaded the app and enrolled in the trial. We anticipate 216-275 vehicles. Daily observations could be up to 714 per vehicle (17,136 hourly observations). These vehicles make up the 20-28 distribution groups
Arms
Managed: 7 distribution groups (70 cars) Time-of-Use: 7 distribution groups (70 cars) Control: 8 distribution groups (76 cars)
Primary outcomes
Phase 2: Distribution group hourly charge, distribution group daily peak/off peak/total charge, household and vehicle hourly charge, household and vehicle daily peak/off peak/total charge, distribution group violation indicator (hourly and daily) and violation magnitude by hour (in kWh), charge indicators for whether cars are plugged in (hourly and daily), distribution group transformer charging room (hourly and daily), compliance with treatment Phase 3: Same as Phase 2 outcomes plus household-level indicator for whether it opts into the offered incentive program for shifting charging
Secondary outcomes
We will also collect data on costs of distribution system upgrades and distribution network outages from the utility to quantify the benefits of shifting EV charging times.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords